|
Dear Doc:
How can I help my daughter see that her boyfriend is mooching off of all of us (her, her father, and me) without alienating her?
Response:
Have you spoken to her directly yet diplomatically?
Bottom Line:
If that won't work, start to set up boundaries for yourself (because we can never really control others feelings and viewpoints). Do not let him mooch off of you. Hopefully your daughter will see the value of your role model, and will come to figure it out for herself as a result.
Dear Doc:
Hello - I've lost my way, and this is driving me insane. I have no one else to turn to. My boyfriend and I broke up a while back, but he said he didn't want to lose me, so we decided to stay friends. But lately its been killing me, because I still care for him and I miss him. It's harder because we work together, and he smiles at me, and I try to smile back, but all I want is to take it slow and hang out like old times, but the problem is I don't know how to tell him to hang out, without directly asking. Please help!
Response:
So ask him straight up! As they say, don't ask don't get.
Bottom Line:
What do you have to lose? If he says no, it should help you to get over him!
Dear Doc:
Living with boyfriend whose behavior is becoming more erratic. Masks symptoms with alcohol, then becomes a different person. Also has a son 24 who is mentally ill, living here with us, being forced to move out by boyfriend, who has recently started blaming me for everything. Work in the healthcare field; just tried to help him. Behavior is getting worse. Should I leave him alone?
Response:
Absolutely leave him alone, because you can't make the horse drink the water.
Bottom Line:
You should also consider moving out and living on your own, as this relationship doesn't sound very rewarding.
Dear Doc:
i am 34 years old been married to same man since i was 15, we have had our ups and downs but i always thought we would grow old together. i have been through his abuse verbally and emotionally,stayed with him when he did drink and he would disappear,porn,so on. his parents were not good at all as parents.he quit drinking and seemed good for a while now angry all time. since my back and other disabilities gotten worse he wants me gone. i caught him chatting on cell phone and think stopped but dont matter something is up how can he turn off his heart for me like this. my grandmother died,dad is dying,and im very sick and he cusses me other day tried to strangle me thats when our 17 year old son said its it. my son says hes not man enough to support me through all my issues. still want know what is happening. he made me go to a wedding rehearsal to show some buddies how gorgeous his wife was and they all flipped out but when we get home hes mean as hell to me. im so sick and disability check is low what am i gonna do. im scared ive been him so long.i know i got to leave but please any tips and also what could be wrong him or is he cheating,or midlife,or looking,or a narcissist,is very controlling,his parents blame me,course they are weird, i cant stop wandering cause love i have is so deep. thanks.
Response:
There's your answer, in your last sentence. Why in the world do you stay with this guy?? Leave as fast as you can! The cause of this seems simple... he does not love you or the family enough.
Bottom Line:
It will be harder on your kids to be around this ugly relationship, than to adjust to a new and healthier life without him in the house.
Dear Doc:
I am a medical graduate married to one who did not complete high school who was my love. We have 3 kids 9, 6 and 5 years old. After a few months of marriage only I found that My husband believes that his responsibility for family is just fulfilling family needs with money. He does not want to be involved in any family activity like taking care, spending time, eating with the family etc. Everything he does only after forcing or long explanation about its advantages or after verbal fight. Now these things are effecting our kids. For even simple things about family matters I have to explain a lot. Another problem with him is that he shows himself outside differently, and most of the things he does just for showing outsiders that he is good in status, good with wife, like he is working hard for his family etc. Whereas things are quite different behind the screen. We suffer a lot with his arguments, misbehaving, abusive language and many more. Nowadays wherever he goes, friends, relatives or anywhere, he tells them that I am not good with him, I do not respect him and I don't take care of him. I have helped him in every way Financially, Morally, being supportive, especially in the period when we had a great loss in business during which even his parents and brothers left him, and did not help him, but I worked even during my pregnancy so that it will support my husband and kids. He never appreciates me, but keeps on blaming me that I am not good with him. I am fed up with his behaviour. I want to know the cause. Nowadays for any simple thing also he says he doesn't want to live with me.
Response:
There's your answer, in your last sentence. Why in the world do you stay with this guy?? Leave as fast as you can! The cause of this seems simple... he does not love you or the family enough.
Bottom Line:
It will be harder on your kids to be around this ugly relationship, than to adjust to a new and healthier life without him in the house.
Dear Doc:
My 8 yr old daughter wants to play organized football in a league that consist of boys her age. She is very althletic and physical. My concerns are about her physically hurting herself, and the affects that it could have on her sexual identity. Am I overreacting?
Response:
Yes you are. She may be the best athelete on the team. Many girls play "boy" sports without getting hurt or confusing their sexual identity.
Bottom Line:
If it's not right for her, she will drop out on her own accord. If you try to hold her back, it will only hurt your relationship with her. So go tell her to go kick some boy butt, and support her in her choices!
Dear Doc:
How do I deal with my marijuana smoking ex-husband and his ex-wife drug addict? They are influencing my 3 yr old son. They are both sleeping with each other and other people, while consuming drugs and alcohol around my son and the daughter they share together.
Response:
You could discuss this with your local Child Protective Services officer, to see if the government can take any action. However, your ex may not be breaking the law. You could also try to get full custody of your son, but that could become prohibitively expensive. Finally, you could try to move your son out of the state, but the law may not allow that.
Bottom Line:
If all this fails, you will have to teach him about right and wrong when he is with you, and hope that he makes the right choices as he grows up.
Dear Doc:
My 8 yr old daughter wants to play organized football in a league that consist of boys her age. She is very althletic and physical. My concerns are about her physically hurting herself, and the affects that it could have on her sexual identity. Am I overreacting?
Response:
Yes you are. She may be the best athelete on the team. Many girls play "boy" sports without getting hurt or confusing their sexual identity.
Bottom Line:
If it's not right for her, she will drop out on her own accord. If you try to hold her back, it will only hurt your relationship with her. So go tell her to go kick some boy butt, and support her in her choices!
Dear Doc:
I'm 27 years old. At 19, I had sex for the first time with my "friend"... And 8 years later, I'm still sleeping with him, even when he has a girlfriend. At least once a year. Every time we see each other, we sleep together. And for the past 3 years, every time we see each other, he keeps asking me "What are we going to do about this chemistry? Do you think we will ever be friends? I don't think we can." He keeps saying "he's no good for me" that he would be a horrible boyfriend... but he keeps initiating sex! The thing is, I NEVER asked him for a relationship, so I don't understand where this is coming from! Do you have an opinion on this? My "woman brain" has a ton of explanations, but I would love an outsider's opinion. Why would a man sleep with the same woman for EIGHT YEARS? I don't get it.
Response:
Because he likes the sex. If it wasn't for societal rules, many men would not be monogamous.
Bottom Line:
As long as you keep giving it, he will probably keep taking it. Say no to him, and you will see the real him, which is probably a person who you do NOT want to spend time with.
Dear Doc:
I need help fast. My brother is currently in a mental facility for Bipolar mental illness. This facility is mistreating him. The healthcare professionals are very rude to us when we visit with him every week. How can we get more help? My 73 year old mother has talked to a lawyer who told her he has another case of this kind of treatment from the same facility. Please help.
Response:
Did he place himself there, or is he being held against his will? If he placed himself there, then he should leave there, and find a better facility. If he is being held there against his will, then an attorney is the best way to go.
Bottom Line:
But if he wants to stay, there is nothing you can do, unless he has given up the right to make his own care decisions.
Dear Doc:
i really hope u can help me asap. i'm 17 years old and 6 months pregnant. i'm going to college. i got my ged. i'm getting a car. my boyfriend is wonderful, but i'm so depressed and i've suffered from this for a long time. an old counselor of mine said it's probably just nerves from the pregnancy, but i feel like it's too much. i'm always depressed and i'm afraid it's hurting my baby. please, do you have any ideas to help me? it's not just mild, but extreme. i tried talking to my doctor, and all she will tell me is take anti-depressants, but i'm really afraid to do that. plus, i don't wanna have to rely on pills to make me better. i've given up my addiction to prescription pills, and i did ok with marijuana for a few months, but everything has become so hard. i've been ocasionally smoking. it's making me hate myself more, but i don't know what to do, and i've begged for help. please help me doc.
Response:
You need a Doctor who will take you seriously. It may be that your depression is caused by hormonal changes during your pregnancy, and will pass after birth. It's definitely more than nerves, and you don't want to be on anti-depressants while you are pregnant. It is unlikely that it is hurting your child. You are correct to not take any foreign substances while you are pregnant. This will most likely pass. Try to find a support group of pregnant teens, so you can learn from their experiences. A change in your diet may improve your mood.
Bottom Line:
Above all hang in there, get through the birth, and then tackle your depression with meds, if nothing else works. Depression can run in families, so don't discount the potential medical side of the problem.
Dear Doc:
What is the normal, healthy-adult response to hurting your husband's feelings (in frustration) but realizing that the ISSUE over which you hurt is feelings is real? My husband is a know-it-all. He insists on taking on major projects in our home by himeself, with no input from others ("they don't know, *I* know"), but has a history of either completing them badly or not completing them. Yet he doesn't see how this history affects my mental state or our financial state (I am the sole breadwinner, so I end up paying for his mistakes). Today we had a blow-out over a project he wants to redo (waterproofing our basement). He did it VERY badly the first time, creating ill-will with the neighbors, costing lots of money, and NOT solving the problem. He refuses to get professional assistance to do it this time. My fear of going through this project again caused me to vent a LOT of frustration about his role (or lack, thereof) in our household. I downplayed his importance and abilities. I feel bad about that, because he is (or was, anyway) proud of his abilities -- I just don't feel the same way about them, any more. Now - I feel bad for hurting his feelings, and I would like to give him another chance to fix the problem - but the arrogance about his abilities scares me. We have a history of me being the apologist, after arguments, because I'm a "peace keeper" (even if the argument is not generated by me). So I want to apologize for hurting his feelings, but don't want that apology to be the "free pass" to him thinking he can go ahead, unassisted, to screw up this project. How would people in a marriage with good communication resolve this? Ours (clearly) is NOT one of those, but I'm trying to move in that direction...
Response:
You need to get over your need to apologize. You spoke the truth...he sucks at home repair. He needs to admit that before you allow any money for repairs. And THEN you need to get someone else to do it!
Bottom Line:
Maybe he's trying to find his ego and self worth in house repairs, when he needs to find his strokes in other areas where he is actually talented. Help him with that, and you will be on your way to better days.
Dear Doc:
I'd like some advice on what to do about my 31 year old stepson who my husband gave a housekey to, just letting himself in without calling or even knocking. He also assumes one of our spare bedrooms as his own. He piles his own stuff in there, not allowing our space. His sense of entitlement and disrespect are causing resentment between my husband and me. My husband won't say anything to his son. What should I do? I feel angered by this and have to leave my own home because of the tensions felt.
Response:
The problem is between you and your husband. Sharing children can be most difficult. Truly, blood is thicker than water. For watever reason, your husband accepts his son's behavior.
Bottom Line:
All you can do is frankly speak with your husband, and possibly your stepson, about your discontent. If your husband won't change the rules, you will have to live with them, or move on.
Dear Doc:
I have two adult disabled sons on ventilators and in wheelchairs that live with me, as well as an older adult son. We have been divorced from their father for 24.5 years. I have been more than accommodating for him to see his sons. This month he has come over unannounced every single day when ever he feels like it, and stays for hours. When he arrives he texts me and says that he is here. He does not provide for his disabled sons in anyway at all. The state is meeting the needs that I can't meet. I teach school full time and use much of my paycheck to get them what they need that is not covered by insurance, medi-cal and SSI. He also trys to touch me and does not respect any boundaries. I feel like telling him can only come at certain times would be like waving a red flag in front of a bull. How can I protect myself without alienating my sons. It is adding much too much stress to an already very difficult life.
Response:
You HAVE to draw a line in the sand. If need be, get a restraining order against him.
Bottom Line:
You can't worry about alienating the boys right now. If you don't protect yourself, the whole system will implode.
Dear Doc:
My 15 year old hangs out with his friends and is disrepecting my house by coming in at 1:00am in the morning, two or three time a week. He has been told time and time again, but continues to do it. My husband says he can't take it anymore and he is leaving. But the problem is not me and him, it's my 15 year old. We are getting a divorce because of this. What can I do about this teenager?
Response:
It sounds like the tail is wagging the dog. Is this your husband's son also? Your son keeps doing it, because you let him get away with doing it. This is certainly no reason for a divorce. Maybe there are some other underlying issues. Put your foot down. Lock your son out of the house, and don't let him in after whatever time you set. Until you lay down the law, he will walk all over you. Maybe his goal (possibly subconscious) is to get your husband to leave, so that he can be the top male in the house.
Bottom Line:
It may sound harsh, but he is still a boy, and it's your job to reign him in. Your husband needs to help with this.
Dear Doc:
Ok...here it goes...this man and I have been dating exclusively for five years, while we both live in separate houses. His kids live far away, while mine have grown up with me. I wanted to marry this man, but now, I've noticed he seems to be in a mid life crisis. I'm beginning to wonder what I loved about him in the first place. He does have a good side, but things just aren't right. So, how do I suggest that we still see each other, but that I need time to work on myself and my future (what is left of it)? If he can't handle your honesty, it may be time for you to move on from him!
Response:
Let's try honesty. Tell him that you want to see him, but that marriage doesn't interest you right now. There are lots of couples with adult children who find that it is more enjoyable to stay single, while dating someone long-term.
Bottom Line:
You are correct that what is most important is for you to get your head clear, and to live the life that works best for you. Don't let him or anything else get in the way of that!
Dear Doc:
I am coming home from being deployed to Iraq for 11 months in a couple of weeks.
About 6 months ago, I let my parents and siblings know the 3 or 4 days that I likely would be coming back, so someone could come pick me up.
My car is at my parents' house, 2.5 hours away from where we get dropped off so I am not able to drive myself to their house.
A couple of months ago, my sister said she would pick me up when I got home, but now she is saying she has to go out of town on business that week and another day she and her husband are taking their kids to watch a fire training demonstration to watch a house burn since a family friend is a firefighter (!!??).
I feel hurt by this. Also, I feel a bit afraid to ask my brother to take a day from work to pick me up, since he gets angry and upset when plans change suddenly.
And, my parents are old now and probably should not drive there to get me because it would also involve sitting through a "welcome home" ceremony in midday summer heat.
My background is that both parents were both physically and emotionally abusive toward me when I was young.
When I was 16 years old, I stopped eating and my Mom took me to counseling for 6 months after my Dad yelled at me really badly for a period of time at home.
My one marriage ended in divorce 10 years ago after my ex-husband punched me and otherwise was abusive and since then, I had a very abusive ex-boyfriend that I am trying hard not to be in contact with, even now.
It just seems like I can't count on my parents or siblings as family for emotional support and, at the same time, I have gotten into these two abusive relationships with men so far in my life.
I actually enjoyed being overseas away from there, even though I've been in a combat zone. It seemed less stressful in some ways to me than my life at home.
Now I am feeling sad and anxious about going back there.
My parents would like me to stay for part of my vacation time with them.
My family sent me packages of things and food while I have been gone, and my Mom watched my cats for me (although one died), so I feel I OUGHT to spend time with them when I get home.
They have always provided material things and even money to me so I feel badly to complain or not to see them when I get home. And, also, I do care about them because they are my parents.
The idea that I am coming home and no one wants to pick me up just feels very sad.
Would I just be better off not having much interaction with my family in the future?
I feel guilty about that idea because they helped me out a lot, materially.
Also, in the past, I have tended to contact my abusive ex-boyfriend or to respond to his emails or overtures because I feel so bad interacting with my own family.
I feel I have grown a lot being away from there for a year, but now I'm going to be living a mile from the abusive ex-boyfriend again and not too far from parents and siblings again.
I went to domestic violence counseling for a year before I deployed and was in counseling for perhaps 4 years total before that from the divorce and abuse.
The only thing that clicked for me was the domestic violence counseling as I felt they understood what I had been through and how I felt.
Despite these things, I have managed to be part-time military when I'm home and have a full time job on top of that.
Should I just try to start over and just not talk to my family that much? That seems to trigger me toward the destructive behavior of keeping up with my ex, who, despite being abusive, would show up at events that mattered to me.
Response:
It's wrong for your family to not be there for you when you return. The old saying is that we can choose our friends, but we can't choose our family. Can you ask a non-family friend to pick you up? PLEASE don't lean on that abusive ex! You need to NOT get back with him!
Bottom Line:
The world has better people for you. Don't settle for the unhealthy family and exes you have known so far! Yes, definitely start over. Move away if you have to, or maybe take another military assignment away from home. Continue to fight to break away from your abusive past, and your future will be brighter and happier!
Dear Doc:
I was fired from my job in August 2007. Since Jan 2008 I was in school for 2 years for an associates in Social Work. I went in the winter, spring/ summer, fall all in 2008, and right back into winter, spring/summer, fall all in 2009 and winter 2010. My last full year of school is when I started noticing some changes about myself. I was not able to focus, not able to concentrate, easily distracted. I get frustrated, irritated, and I am angry all the time. Sometimes I feel that my education was a big waste of my time and effort. During all this time, I am responsible for another person as well. My husband, who has had his driver's licenses taken away since 2002 for 2 DUI's. We got together in 2003 late November, and now for 7 years he has put off trying to get them back. I do all the driving, everywhere all the time. I do more than he does when it comes to the household chores. Then I have a 21 year old son who has been home from school, and not able to find a steady job, and he is getting on my last nerve. Everyone is getting just exactly all their needs met, and I am the one who is getting nothing in return.
It's time for you to take better care of yourself, so both of those unproductive guys may need to move out (or maybe YOU should go!).
Bottom Line:
You've given out too much, and received too little in return. You need better balance in your life, so take charge, and break away from anything that is too heavy and unfair. That will open the door to a brighter future for you!
Dear Doc:
My daughter's boyfriend is verbally abusing my 8 year old grandaughter. As far as I know its only verbal. My daughter and the boyfriend also have a child together. They both favor her over the 8 year old. Some of the things he says are... I don't love you and I wish you would go away, I wouldn't miss you. Horrible things like that. I think this man is sick. What can I do? My daughter will not listen to me or her 8 year old daughter. I am desperate to help my sweet baby girl. She is always so depressed, that I am afraid for her. She begs me not to say anything.
You absolutely have to say something. It's time to call your state's Child Protective Services.
Bottom Line:
Another alternative would be to have your granddaugher come to live with you. Maybe the state will recommend that. To do nothing is to let her life go down a never-ending path of destruction.
Dear Doc:
I have been with my boyfriend (I hate the sound of that) for 4 yrs. We also have a 2yr old together. He claims that he loves me and wants to spend the rest of his life with me, but doesn't want to marry me because I'm not financially stable. We have had lots of problems in the past. I feel like I should I just give up on this. Please help me!!
You've answered your own question. It's time for you to move on. You deserve better!
Bottom Line:
Talk is cheap. His actions tell the real story, and it's not a pretty one. Go out and find a better life. It's waiting out there for you!
Dear Doc:
I have been married to a man for 5 1/2 years and recently I searched his internet history, out of curosity. I was shocked to find that he was visiting same-sex chat rooms, backpage.com, craigslist ( with a host of links to transexual), trannydate. I confronted him, asking if he has acted on his same-sex fantasies. He vehemently denied even looking at these websites, yet eventually fessed up. I don't believe that he has not engaged in any same sex activities, while we have been married. I am lost and don't know what to do next?
If he hasn't taken physical action to this behavior, he has obviously gone there in his mind, which is significant in and of itself. Either way, he has probably had an emotional and/or physical affair.
Bottom Line:
If you can't stomach this (and many couldn't), you may need to separate for your own sanity. If he will speak the whole truth, and you can forgive, you can try to rebuild. Very very difficult, but not impossible. However, the statistical odds are against a good relationship with him, going forward. Very very tough choices, either way. But be strong and true to yourself, and you will make it to the other side regardless!
Dear Doc:
i am a widow of just about 4 years. i just started seeing a wonderful man 6 months ago, after i promised myself i would never fall in love again. but here i am. well anyway, he has been married twice and as a young son. he says he loves me, wants me to move in. etc. i just want to see if anyone has any suggestions of what might.............
It's great to enjoy him, but why the need for a move in? I'm wondering if he's looking for someone to baby-it and do the chores!
Bottom Line:
A little distance can be a great thing in a relationship. I certainly would not recommend a move-in after six months, unless maybe your goal is to ruin the relationship in the NEXT six months! Add a child into the mix, and that is not a road you probably want to go down right now.
Dear Doc:
My boyfriend calls me names when he's angry. I try to talk about it later, but he gets offended, and says I've got problems. Help.
Your problem may be that you have the wrong boyfriend!!
Bottom Line:
You deserve better. Doesn't sound like he is going to change. If so, move on to someone who treats you the way you WANT to be treated!
Dear Doc:
I have finally found a dear friend from college 40 years ago. I didn't hire a private investigator to find him, but thought many times about the great fun we had in the dorm (first floor), and how precious those years were, yet I did not realize it at the time. I did ask other friends about him from time to time, but received little results. I would love to talk with him about so many things, and how knowing him changed my life as a naive South Dakotan. Do you think it is worth while pursuing a conversation with him, or should I just remember life as it was when I was young? Ron Ortman, Marion South Dakota. p.s. I haven't been praying for him for all these years, if that makes a difference.
Hi Ron! Long time no chat, for sure! If you're referring to our time together in Omaha, I would always love to chat. Just shoot me a note through my website, with your email address. If you are referring to another, it is never too late to rekindle old friendships. We just have to be aware that some people change over time, so they might not be as we remember them.
Bottom Line:
Did Al Wiens give you the name of my website??
Dear Doc:
i went through my boy friend's phone, and i found that he is cheating. when i asked him about it, he never replied. instead, he blamed me for going through his phone. we didn't contact each other for a month. he came to me after that, saying he missed me. but when i asked about the cheating, he still didn't say a thing, and still blamed me. i forgave him, cuz i was missing him a lot, but know i regret forgiving him. what should i do?
Run like the wind, as far from him as you can get!!
Bottom Line:
You are ASKING to get hurt again. If he won't honestly confess it, then he is a bum. He WILL hurt you again. You deserve better, and are wiser to go through the challenge of getting over him, so that you can have a better future with someone who treats you with the respect you deserve.
Dear Doc:
My boyfriend is returning from completing an alcohol residential program. What should I expect when he returns? He told me he has changed. I feel that he has gained self worth and confidence, but will his feelings change towards our love for each other? We had a great relationship for two years. I am not a drinker or a drug abuser. I just want to be there for him, but I am afraid to lose him.
Unfortunately, this sounds dangerous. If you had a good relationship while he was an alcoholic, and if he will truly stay clean and sober now, he will certainly be something of a different person going forward.
Bottom Line:
Unfortunately, his chances of fallng off the wagon are high, statistically speaking. Try to be there for him, but also prepare yourself for the reality that the two of you may not fit, if alcohol is taken out of the equation. I hope your relationship is better after he comes back, but it may take more work than you expect.
Dear Doc:
Hi! My name is Vennetta. I'm married to an alcoholic and abusive spouse. Can you have your spouse committed to any type of facility when he has become a danger to himself and others?
If the police or a Doctor agree with you, they can have him committed against his will.
Bottom Line:
If that doesn't happen, you need to get away from him immediately, and not let him know where you are. There are Battered Women's organizations that can help, and the police can help you find them.
Dear Doc:
I have been married for 15 years, and we have 3 kids, ages 13,12 and 9. My husband just confessed that he is having an affair that has been going on now for the last 3 years. What should I do? If I stay because of our kids and I love him, how will I cope, knowing that he is still seeing and sleeping with this woman?
You undoubtedly won't cope well if he continues this, and doesn't put out efforts to make things right with you.
Bottom Line:
If that is the case, it will be healthier for you to leave. That would likely be one of the hardest things you have ever done, but if you are not ok, your kids won't be ok either. Let's hope that he cares enough about you and the kids to stop this behavior.
Dear Doc:
What do you call a person who repeats himself on and on about the same topic and things that happened in the past?
A pain in the butt!
Bottom Line:
Actually, this is what a narcissist does. Everything is all about them. All they want is an audience. This is usually a sign of some real insecurities. This may well be a person that you don't want to spend too much time with!
Dear Doc:
im 17 yrs old and have been dating my boyfriend for about a year now. my parents don't really no we're dating, and can't know, because of religious differences. they think he's a bad influence on me, but from my perspective, i feel that i make my own decisions, and i am 100% responsible for my own actions. now i've changed my ways and i'm on the right path. but still, as a result of how they feel, they want me to put a restraining order against him to prove to them that i'm not seeing him. i love him with all my heart, and that's definitely the last thing i want to do. but if i say, no i'm not doing that, then that proves we are dating, in their eyes... what do i do?
Don't do it.
Bottom Line:
A restraining order is a very harsh reaction, which is saved for those who abuse us or threaten our lives. Your parents are unwisely painting you into a corner where you can't win. Just say no. You will soon be 18. If they make your life hell, you may have to move on as an adult without them after your birthday.
Dear Doc:
Can the narcissist cling to and emulate the person who neglected them as a child?
Absolutely.
Bottom Line:
The narcissist does not see their sickness, but they are looking for love from those who abandoned their heart as a child. That is part of what makes the disorder so insidious.
Dear Doc:
hi. I am 16yrs and my periods have been going on for 2 months now... it has started for 7 days when i started to see it and then 2 weeks then 3 weeks then a month. although in between its stops. but i just want my periods to be regular instead of irregular...i need help :( pleassse...
You need to go to a Medical Doctor today!
Bottom Line:
When we think that something is wrong with us physically, it only does us more harm to try to figure it out by ourselves. We need the expert medical opinion of a good Doctor to help us get better.
Dear Doc:
Why does my alcoholic husband get angrier and angrier every day about nothing?
Because he is in denial about the misery he is in, and lashes out at others because he is too afraid to look inside himself in order to improve his situation.
Bottom Line:
In reality, he is mad at himself, because he cannot conquer his alcoholism. If he will not go get help, you should further distance yourself from him.
Dear Doc:
I have a 15 year old daughter who is "miserable" because she has no friends. However, she takes the attitude that: "I won't talk to anyone new, unless they approach me first" which has resulted in her not making any new friends since we moved from our previous home in Arizona 3 years ago. She is VERY headstrong, VERY smart, and VERY manipulative of Mom. She became anorexic in the last 6 months as she went from weighing 145lbs, down to 105 pounds (fully clothed), stopped having menstrual cycles, and losing hair. All this while telling us she wants to move from our home in Virginia back to Arizona to be with her old friends. However, she would still be over 40 miles away from them, and still (mainly) be in contact with them via the phone. There is MORE to the story, however, as she wants to move in with her older Sister who is 23, and VERY (financially) IRRESPONSIBLE. So, the older Sister would get her rent paid by US (partially, even though she is ALREADY 3 thousand dollars in debt to us for past rent!!!) because she knows we won't let her younger Sister be kicked out on the street!! So, HERE is my question: Should we let her move to Arizona to be "happy", or not? I think it would be allowing her to run away from her problems with making new friends(enabling poor social skills, and not making her face her fear) while also enabling the older Sister to keep acting irresponsibly with her money, because she will have us to fall back on. My wife says I don't care about our Daughter's happiness, but I beg to differ. I used the old saying "give a man a fish, and he can eat for a day, but TEACH a man to fish, and he can eat for a lifetime". I feel we need to TEACH our 15 year old to "fish" instead of "giving her a fish". Am I crazy wrong about this?. I also don't think it's a good idea given her anorexia. I feel she needs to understand we all have to deal with being away from our friends in Arizona, and she just has to learn to cope with it in a more healthy way.
The answer is "no".
Bottom Line:
You are on the right track. My family moved when I was 11 and my brothers were 15 and 18. It certainly can be tough, but we don't learn by going backwards. She'll hate you for awhile, but probably thank you by the time she is 18.
Dear Doc:
I've been having a hard time lately with many things in my life, but I just read all my questions to you from over the past 3 years and it helped me put everything into persective. I've grown so much and now I'm realizing that what my next step is my spiritual life. Not in an organized religious sense, more in univeral interconnected sense..nature. I'm not at all sure what I mean by this, but I know that that is the missing link. In the last three years I not only got into a car accident, I got divorced, moved, quit the company I started, got so sick from an antibiotic that I almost died, got fired from my job while in the hospital and getting divorced, got another job that turned out to be very "moochy" and didn't pay me on time while trying to flatter me into a "too good to be true partnership" (which i rejected and suddenly my job was not really existing anymore) then went to grad school and here I am. Also, through all this, I discovered in myself that my brother and i were both sexually abused, I went to therapy for this and it really helped. When it rains it pours! So now here I am, feeling drained, but somehow hopeful. I feel like i'm ready to kick this up to the next level of growth. I cry a lot, but it feels great.
Keep up the good (but difficult) work!
Bottom Line:
Your life will bring you long term benefits, as you conquer your mountains.
Dear Doc:
I have a stepson who is very agressive. He is 17 years old about to be 18 and is a spoiled brat. If he is asked to do anything (like clean his room up) he raises hell screams and cusses his dad, he got in my face screaming at me and slapping his hands together in my face because his dad told him he would not let me wash his clothes or do for him anymore because he treats me so ugly and does not appreciate it. As soon as he got in the door (slammed it) came up to me and got in my face started screaming and slapping his hands together in my face, his dad jerked him out of my face and actually spanked him on the rear hard. The boy is 6 ft 3 and I am 5 ft tall. I am sick of his behavior and a nervous wreck in my own house. We have had him in counseling for over a year. There is a lot more to it, my husbands family treats the stepson like he is a victim and he should not have to do anything we should be his slaves. I am at my wits end. What do you suggest?
It sounds like a dangerous situation. It's time for either he or you to move out.
Bottom Line:
If his father's family is so supportive of him, he should go live with them. Then they will realize how out of control he is.
Dear Doc:
my girlfriend is a recovering alcoholic with 3 yrs sober. she recently started having some female problems. her ob doctor is not sure what is wrong. she has severe pain she says, in her ovaries. i feel like she is fixing to relapse because of the pain. she says she is losing control. i hate to see her lose everything she has worked so hard for. WHAT CAN I DO TO HELP HER? please any advice.
All you can do is try to support her, and try to help her get some first rate help.
Bottom Line:
In the end, it is always up to the individual to pull through their difficulties. It's hard on us to watch, but we cannot fix the other person.
Dear Doc:
My husband is 63yrs old and I am 48yrs. We have 1 son 10yrs old, and are married 14yrs. I work as a med.tech/supervisor in a nursing home. Mhusband is retired, and stays home. I just found out that he's fooling around. Sometimes the lady call's my house. I told him that I will divorce him, but he says that I can't take my son. He will take my son because my son gets benefits from social security. My husband is the one keeping my son's money. What are my rights as a working mother? Every time my son is sick I am always the one who takes care of him. He never takes care of my son good. He never treats my son well.
You need to contact an attorney asap. If that is too expensive, contact a local women's organization that helps oppressed women. Often they have people who can help you for free.
Bottom Line:
You have lots of rights, and your husband is ignoring all of them! You deserve much better than this. Don't put up with this poor treatment. Keep looking, and you will find good people who will help you and your son get out of this unhealthy relationship!
Dear Doc:
My husband of 12 years has all of a sudden decided he wants to live the single life but while he is he expects me to hang around waiting in case he decides it's not for him. His dr recently suggested he may be bi polar but he has never gone back for more diagnosis and although he has left me, now everything from the third world debt to the tsunami is my fault. He's constantly angry and I'd like to help him but how? He also drinks approx 20-30 cups of coffee a day.
I don't think I'd hang around!! It's not your job to help him. If he doesn't want to change, it will never happen.
Bottom Line:
That's enough caffeine for a whole football team!! Become your own healthy person. Find your own way. If he changes, and you then decide to be with him, that will make for a healthier marriage.
Dear Doc:
How do i tell my boyfriend to fix himself up a little bit better without him thinking that i'm trying to change him or hurt his feelings? I wish he could try a little bit.
You are trying to change him, and he probably needs it! Just be honest. You are not in charge of his feelings, so if they are hurt, that's his responsibility.
Bottom Line:
The relationship isn't healthy if you can't be honest. If he can't handle it, then you need to find a healthier boyfriend!
Dear Doc:
I just found out that my boyfriend of five years has fathered a set of twins who are 6 months old. I found out because the mom has petitioned the court for child support. We have had a rocky relationship but I don't know whether I should end things orbit. He is 25 and I am 24. He now has four kids which includes the child we have together who is three years old. This is apparently not the first time he's cheated. I was able to contact the mom and she informed me of at least two other women he dated while they were dating. I knew nothing. What should I do?
I hope you're kidding. What should you do?? You should run like hell, that's what you should do!!
Bottom Line:
Please tell me that you believe that you and your child deserve better treatment than this. Throw this guy out with the garbage, where he belongs! If need be, go it alone, holding your head up high, as you look for a much better world in which to live! Because believe me, it's out there, guaranteed.
Dear Doc:
I am a female who has been raped 5 times over my life time. I have constant flashbacks. The one thing that happens to me is I have a severe urge to masterbate frequently. I actually look at this as punishment for having been raped. I am single and really know nothing about sex except what I know from being raped. I hate myself when I have masterbated. I cannot control the urge. I have a very hard time talking about this. I have a therapist that I basically have told about my rapes but have not spoken about the masterbation, as I am ashamed and angry that if I don't do it then I look for ways to hurt myself.
Your experience is not unusual, but you can overcome this significant difficulty.
Bottom Line:
Your therapy is of little use if you don't share the masterbation information with your counselor. If you are uncomfortable with this person, find another with whom you can be totally honest. If you don't, you won't be able to break this painful cycle that you are in.
Dear Doc:
My husband is a Pastor and he has a poblem with internet pornography? what can I do to help him? we have been married for 16 years and I do not want to lose my husband.
Does HE think he has a problem? Little change will occur until he does.
Bottom Line:
If he will not change his behavior, you will have to consider what choices you have on your end.
Dear Doc:
I dated this guy for over five years. We met when I was 16. We loved each other very much and wanted to spend our lives together (we still do). That scared me because I felt like I was not going anywhere and neither was he. Unless something crazy happened chances are we would not break up. The fear pushed me and I broke up with him because I wanted to see what else was out there before making this life long commitment at only 21 at the time. I told him I was no longer in love with him. We broke up and 3 months later I realized the mistake I made and contacted him. I found out he had a girlfriend and we both agreed to remain friends. After two months of conversations we both admitted that we were still very much in love with each other. I then told him he needed to make a choice because if you love me the way you say you do then you should be with me. He said he can’t just break up with her and that it needs to be a process because he has become acquainted with her family and she has with his family. He also claims that he does not love her and does not see a future with her. He says his future is with me and wants to spend the rest of his life with me. If this is the case why can't he break up with her and be with me? I feel like he is lying and he does love the girl because if you don't love her or see a future then why are you with her? We have so much history and the love we share is indescribable then why not be with me? I feel like he is more concerned with her feelings than mine. Every time we see each other the chemistry is strong. We always end up making out and we would probably have sex, but I always stop him because, though I love him, I know it is wrong. I recently told him we need to stop what we are doing and give each other space and he needs to come to me when he is single. Now I am starting to feel like maybe that was not the right choice. I just don’t know why he is choosing her over me if he claims we are going to be together any way.
You made th right choice to step away from him again. Sure sounds like he is working both sides of the street.
Bottom Line:
You are still terribly young. Go out there and meet new people. You deserve better than what he is offering. If he comes back later, and your available, then so be it. If not, then you've found a better world.
Dear Doc:
My husband and I have separated after 20 years of marriage. Now that he's single he has begun to drink and smoke pot after 18 years of sobriety. We reconcile then after stress/anxiety overwhelms him we fight and he goes back to his place. Our teenage children go over on weekends and they keep secrets from me that includes their Dad buying beer and smoking pot with them. I always feel like such a fool when I go over there to pick him up for some appointment we have--only to learn his attentiveness to me was to get me out of there before I saw something he knows would make me mad. Last weekend, we were still in reconciliation mode. I was annoyed that he disappears on the weekends to go over to his house (because the teenage kids can't be left alone) and I'm left with our little ones all weekend. I knew he smoked pot but I discovered that he bought beer for our 15 year old daughter and was smoking pot. So, I had him get all his stuff out of my place and dropped him off. I also called child protective services on him. Where is the man I was married to for all those years that I was so in love with? What the hell is happening to him?
You did the right thing, for the welfare of your kids. A lot of people change over time, and often not for the better. And when you add alcohol and drugs into the mix, the person may go down a dark road and never return.
Bottom Line:
It sounds like you are being used. Take better care of yourself, and don't put up with his games. Living without him permanently may be your healthiest long-term move.
Dear Doc:
I don't know if I have the problem or my husband and daughter do. My husband has always shut me out when I try to talk to him. I should mention he is an alcoholic and he is especially like this if it is about his drinking, but it can be anything. If he doesn't want to talk about it he stonewalls and just shuts me out, won't listen, and gets angry if I persist in trying to discuss with him things that I think I have a right to talk to him about. Then he will comment that I just won't stop. Well, the issue isn't resolved and I am angry that he just shuts down communication with no resolution. So on to my 20-year-old daughter. I suspect that my daughter is copying her dad's behavior but maybe it's just me. But SHE also comments that I just won't give it up when I'm trying to talk to her, yet to me it seems dysfunctional for a family NOT to discuss important things. Like today I told her she needed to make sure she enrolls in classes for next semester because last I knew she hadn't. She said she had enrolled in one so far, macroeconomics. I asked what macroenomics was for. She is taking classes at junior college and I want to make sure I know what she is going toward and that the classes will transfer, since we are paying for school, apartment, etc. Her sister took random classes and it is going to take her 6 years to finish because she took random courses that she really didn't need, and we have discussed that she (younger daughter) needs to know what she is going toward and not just take random classes that aren't for her major or that won't transfer. She said she didn't want to talk about it and that she didn't want to get upset with me, so to just drop it. I figure as long as we are paying for school I have a right to know what she is taking and where she is going with it. I told her that and she ended up throwing a fit, throwing things on the floor and storming out. Since when is it wrong to discuss things? Am I right in thinking it's dysfunctional NOT to discuss things like this? I don't understand getting so upset about me wanting to know what she is taking in school. And when she gets upset like this she will say "Dad knows you are like this too." And when my husband gets upset with me he'll say "You do the same thing to the kids. You just won't stop." Well I don't stop because I try to have a conversation with people who won't discuss the things I'm trying to discuss. I have two other kids and they are not like this. But my husband says I ask too many questions. What mother doesn't ask her kids questions like where are you going? Who with? When will you be back? What are you taking in school? How will that count toward the degree you are going for? I'm sick of them acting like I am the one doing something wrong when I really don't think I am. If it's me, I want to know so I can do something about it, but I feel like I'm being a normal mom like any other mom and I feel like my husband has warped ideas about family communication(either because of his alcoholism or because he grew up without a mother and maybe doesn't know what a mother is like) and that his behavior is being modeled by this daughter. I know other families who discuss everything and I get in "trouble" if I try to have a discussion about anything with mine. Sorry so long.
The dysfunctional title seems to fit. I wonder what your other kids think. Maybe you should stop paying, if you're not satisfied with her responses. And maybe you need to stop being with your husband. Sure doesn't sound like a loving situation.
Bottom Line:
All we can change is ourselves. If I were you, I'd quite talking to the two of them about the subjects that go nowhere. Build your own world with people who want to communicate with you. These two don't, and it's a waste of your time.
Dear Doc:
What should I do if my sister in law is nasty one visit and nice the next?
Don't reinforce this negative behavior. Step away when you are treated poorly, or speak directly to the problem.
Bottom Line:
You deserve better than this, so if she persists, you need to stop spending time with her.
Dear Doc:
Hi. A few months ago i had a really painful breakup with a boyfriend of 3 years. I found out that he was cheating on me. i think that that was the worst day of my life. im sure it was the best day of his; he didnt have to be with me anymore. i feel like he cheated because of me, like i led him to it. he must be so happy without me. i still love him so much it hurts. i sometimes pray that i will have a dream about him so that i can see him and hear his voice, i know that's kinda weird. sometimes i can really feel him like he is right near me. i guess i should have known that i couldn't keep a man like him. he deserves better than me. whoever he ends up with is so lucky. what do i do?
Stop blaming yourself, for starters. Your words are those usually heard from abuse victims. You have value. Until you believe that, you can't really go forward.
Bottom Line:
Surely he's not all good, while you're all bad! Discover your strengths, then go out and find someone who values them. Certainly you can do better than THIS guy!
Dear Doc:
My husband has had an emotional affair. How do I know whether he still loves me?
Start by asking him. He may have never stopped loving you. Only time will tell. Affairs are often about many things, other than the loss of love.
Bottom Line:
People stay married for many reasons, other than love. It will be good if the two of you can figure our why he wandered, and what the two of you can do to make sure it doesn't happen again.
Dear Doc:
I have a 12 yr old step daughter who has Attachment Disorder. She's been having issues with school homework. My husband came up with an idea for consequences when she doesn't do her homework. If she doesn't make the right choices to bring her homework home she spends the whole weekend with her grandparents. Being that she has Attachment Disorder is it appropiate to make her spend the weekends at her grandparents? Please advise.
Does not sound like a good idea.
Bottom Line:
And it makes her associate punishment with her grandparents, which is a good way to ruin that relationship.
Dear Doc:
What would you label a person who constantly feels a need to constantly talk, and then repeats himself daily about the same concerns over and over? He also, allows problems to bombard his mind, is negative, critical and not happy with his living standards or choices he has made in life and is not happy if others don't take on the burden with him, then...he gets angry if others don't see things his way, yells and hollars, says mean degrating things then later unapoligitecally, acts like nothing happened. He has lost his sex drive also. and most times, has his own interpretation of things others see differently?
Sounds like a very difficult person person to be around, and one who is very troubled.
Bottom Line:
If he cannot get to the point where he sees his own weaknesses, and is willing to make some improvements, others will likely avoid him.
Dear Doc:
I'd like to give you advice. These people are writing in to you for advice, support, encouragement, etc. How about answering or responding to their heart-felt letters with more than just catchy one liners and short sentences? I think you should give it a try....
Feel free to offer your own advice, and it may be posted right here.
Bottom Line:
This website is fee-for-service (i.e.,their is no advertising revenue), so lengthy answers are given to those who subscribe.
Dear Doc:
i've been dating my bf close to 2 years already. The problem is that he and his parents(mainly just his mom) are always constantly arguing...even yelling at each other. Sometimes the reasons are silly other times they are serious. My bf always talks to me about his problems with them...but i do not know what to say or do. I do not want to take sides or lose his trust. What can i say or do to help him control his anger with them without him thinking that i don't agree with his reason to argue with them. I do not want to completely take his side to where he holds grudges against his parents and remains angry with them. I want to help him forgive without him thinking that i don't understand him.
His folks sound pretty messed up.
Bottom Line:
Take his side, and don't worry about his anger or forgiveness, because you can't control that, and that isn't your problem.
Dear Doc:
This is in response to the stepmother's letter about the addict stepson, the ex "daughter-in law" and the 2 children. I am the mother of the two children and I feel compelled to reply this letter. As soon as I became pregnant with the first child, I turned my life around completely. I had hoped the father would also but this did not happen. Starting with when I gave birth, he actually got kicked out of the hospital for urinating in the utility closet - drunk, drugged. Life was like a roller coaster, doing good for a short time, making promises never kept. There was not one family gathering that he was not messed up on something. I stuck by him even though my family never approved. His family has tried everything to help him. Finally I had enough when he stole my car, wrecked it and ran from the scene, unlicensed and drunk. His family had to spend money on a lawyer for him but he still treated his dad like a dog. My mother had co-signed for the car and she is still payi!
ng off what the insurance didn't cover. I could go tell 100's of embarrassing stories but you get the picture. So, now to the present. I knew it would be hard but didn't want my children around trash. As for catching up with the child support, he is making an effort but I have to drive 30min one way to pick up money that I practically have to beg for. As for catching up, hopefully the state of TN will make sure that happens. One reason he got behind is because his parents fired him after he stole their work van, drunk again - still unlicensed with warrants for his arrest for not going to court. The grandparents have helped by watching the children on some weekends, partly because the father is unfit to be alone with the children. God forbid he would take a whim to take a car with them in it, drunk or drugged. I am a 23 yr old single mother. Two children - 3yrs,and 19mos. I admit that I did go out after work on weekends I didn't have the children. But, I quit the job at a!
sportsbar because I didn't want to be in that environment and it was beginning to be difficult to get a babysitter on weekends. My parents never asked them to pay for daycare, what they said was, we need some help with day care until Chad can pay child support. I admit I've not been good with money but a lot of the tax return money went to mortgage and bills. As for the comment about playing house and having a good time - between now finding a daycare, working the serving job, and trying to find a full time job, getting things in place for school, being a mother, going to Dr.s, etc. there is barely time for leisure. Yes, I did want to go to my sister's bridal shower, and I'll want to go to her wedding - 98% of my social life is with my family. I wasn't trying to manipulate when I mentioned moving to D.C. with my father, I was trying to say that's something I may have to do for survival. After this past weekend I don't want any help from this family other than from the father. I really don't like my kids to be around conflict - they've seen enough with me yelling at their dad to stay sober! Should I just be cordial and let the kids have visits - knowing that they are talking about me in front of the kids? Or should I cut all ties? I hate to be this way, but if they really think what they said about me in this letter is true, then they obviously are total hypocrites - telling me they love me like a daughter, etc. while really thinking otherwise. It makes me think they're all nuts & I don't know if I want my kids around that. What should I do?
Sounds like you may need to move out of town.
Bottom Line:
Too much family can make a person crazy. Maybe a fresh start in a new place will be good for everyone.
Dear Doc:
I met my husband about 10 years ago. I knew at that time that one of his sons was an addict. While in rehab he met a little girl and they now have 2 children. We have helped with the children, by making certain that they were always safe, had food, diapers etc. The mother of the children has improved her life considerably more than the father. They did split up earlier this year. During the past year, we have helped the mother with babysitting so that she could work, and have supplied diapers, milk etc and given her SOME gas money. We were glad that she was making an effort. The childrens' father, my step son, has been good to give her child support, until recently when he lost his job. He is now several weeks behind, but is now working again, and has promised to catch up on his support. Now for the problem, the mother's parents think that my husband and myself should PAY for the mother's day care. I have tried to reach my "step-daughter-in law's" mother to relate everything that has taken place in her absence, But she won't return my calls. I probably don't owe her an explanation, but can't get over the feeling that I must explain my actions. Last year, when the children's mother practically lived with us (the step son was in jail), we fed her, the children, supplied diapers, kept them ALL safe etc. This year, since their separation, we have given up many of our weekends to babysit so that she could work. My husband and I often work 12-15 hour days, and we need our weekends to recuperate. The step d-n-law, on the other hand, missed so much work that she lost her job. It was more important to go out drinking with her friends, go to movies, buy clothes, earrings, etc. than earn an income. I helped her get back over $7000 from income tax, told her to put the money away, so that she would have money for daycare and other expenses so that she could go back to school to better her life. She wasted the money, and now that she is broke her parents expect us to bale her out. Her parents are divorced but make in excess of $200,000 a year, my husband & I make $25,000. The children's mother has also been manipulating everyone, she would call her father, her brother and mother, complaining that the childen's father had only given her $30 implying that was all she had received for the month, when in actuality it was the balance of what was owed for the month. So brother, father etc would send her more money. Instead of paying utilities, she is playing house and having a good time with her friends and her boyfriend. She is staying in her mother's home, rent free, while her mother works out of town, her only responsibilty is utilities, and when her mother returned home from an out of state assignment the utilities were scheduled to be turned off. I believe the girl's family , although with the intention to help her, are enabling her. She is sweet, but manipulating, and now my husband and I are the bad guys. There is much more, but it is difficult to convey it all in a letter. I don't want to enable her, and we are not as financially sound as the girl's parents. Our watching of the children is not totally a selfless act. We enjoy the children and look forward to seeing them and spending time with them. The children's mother has practically threatened us with leaving the state if we don't pay the day care. She then took it back so that we would watch them this weekend freeing her up to go to a bridal shower. What I don't enjoy is having the children be used as a pawn to abstract money from us, which was tried this weekend. What is your take, and what do you recommend?
Do NOT put out any more money. Take her up on her threat to leave the state. That might do you a favor! Develop a mindset where you need her less than she needs you.
Bottom Line:
What her folks do or don't do is up to them. Don't get caught in unhealthy guilt. Live your lives and don't sacrifice all for her. Love the kids where you can.
Dear Doc:
My husband and I have been married for 12 years. I had 3 children when we married. He wanted to be a father. At first things were great. After we had a child of our own, however, things changed. He became aggressive to my children, to the point that I had him arrested. He went through a year of anger management and we got back together. Over time his anger has become more verbal. He also has been caught by my children looking at pornography on the internet. I finally had enough 9 months ago and moved out. He was trying to force my 17 year old son out of our house before he graduated from high school.(my son is now a graduate and is a troop leader in the marines). He had told me I was fat and unattractive after I gained 20 pounds when I quit smoking. He also blamed my weight gain as the cause of his erectile dysfunction. He now tells me that he misses me terribly, can't sleep, can't function etc without me. I met with him and he has made a lot of promises that things will be better. Is it possible that he could change that much? I also have a teenage daughter that I worry about in this environment. I had an appointment with an attorney when he made these promises. I don't feel like I can return to that lifestyle. I'am prepared to follow through but he has not been financially supportive during our separation. What would you advise?
It is very very unlikely that he will change that much. What IS likely is that he wants to avoid the divorce because he will have less money, you will do less for him, etc.
Bottom Line:
Run like the wind, and never look back!
Dear Doc:
My husband and I have been married sixteen years. He was a heavy drinker when we met and continues to drink now, but his drinking rarely interfered with his work. Early in our relationship we discussed having children. I wanted children and he did not. Our situation at the time allowed me to stay at home full-time, and he agreed to have children. Our situation has now changed drastically. He is unemployed and I'm working full time. He resentfully cares for the children while I'm working. He is drinking more heavily than ever before and I have come home from work unexpectedly and found him passed out on the couch while the children were watching television. I am unbearably unhappy and worried sick about the safety of my children. We have discussed this many times and he promises to "be more responsible" but it never lasts more than a few days. I have finally given him an ultimatum, quit drinking and seek professional help or I will file for divorce. He doesn't want the divorce or the rehab and therapy. I'm prepared to follow through, but how do I explain this to our 15 year old daughter and 10 year old son?
You absolutely must follow through with the divorce. The odds of him changing are one in a hundred. Sometimes it is better to be FROM a broken home than to be raised IN a broken home. It will be hard for them at first, but it will be forever better for them down the road. Being raised by an unhappy unemployed alcoholic father is one of life's greatest curses. You have the power to save them from that, so you MUST act now.
Bottom Line:
Tell them that you love them, that it will work out for the best in the long run, and that they can see there dad as much as they want once you separate. Unfortunately, he will probably not follow through in their direction. This will hurt them at first, but as they deal with who and what he really is, they will be healthier as adults.
Dear Doc:
i am living and married to a recovering alcoholic who is angry all the time. he accepts that he is angry, but matters at home fail to improve, and we argue and upset each other all the time. i have two beautiful children under the age of two and want to leave this unhappy environment. i am worried my husband won't cope when i leave and will return to drinking, thus losing everything.
So leave already.
Bottom Line:
You are not in charge of his drinking. What you ARE in charge of is the welfare of your children, which will be ruined if you stay where you are.
Dear Doc:
Advise on the connection between a normal lady in her sixties who is over involved with her son who habitually uses drugs and her father who was an alcoholic.
Sounds like an unhealthy two-generation pattern of rescuing that isn't helping anyone.
Bottom Line:
If you want to get healthy, and possibly start really helping your son, start saying "no", and build some boundaries that are better for everyone. You may be over-helping him because you have an unhealthy desire to be needed.
Dear Doc:
My stepson treats me like i am not part of the family, yet when it comes to buying him things or paying half the bills, i get them handed to me. I never get to go out on a 'date", but the kids get to go and do whatever with their dad. i am not their slave and i am tired of dad not backing me up and making excuses why he does so much for the kids. He ignores my kids, but i am to make my schedules or plans around their needs and wants. i don't think i can tolerate this. why are they treating me like this?
Maybe it's because you let them. It looks like it's time for you to start saying "no", and setting up some healthy boundaries that protect you from such poor treatment.
Bottom Line:
Maybe it's also because they don't like you, and are only using you. In that case, it may be time to pack your bags, for surely you deserve better.
Dear Doc:
My son has OSD and is also an alcoholic. We are trying to get him into treatment but he is becoming more and more paranoid and is now drinking hard alcohol. Please help as we are at a total loss and are afraid he is going to die.
Assuming he is over 17, the unfortunate truth is that you can't force him to make changes. Only he can decide if he wants to go into a treatment program. Some families do an intervention where they get everyone together who loves and cares for him, and you all challenge him at once in a closed room, telling him that he is going to die if he doesn't get treatment. That will sometimes shake the person into reality, where they will finally seek help.
Bottom Line:
If he becomes suicidal, homicidal, or cannot function in society, the police can force him into treatment for a few days. Sometimes that will break his destructive cycle, and lead him to stick with changing and getting long term help.
Dear Doc:
I have no idea what my problem is. My latest theory is that it’s related to some mild form of autism. The view from in here: I just don’t get it. I can’t get a job anywhere, doing anything. No matter how I dumb-down my resume. I worked before my kids were born and had some decent skills. Then I voluntarily stayed home for a while. I went back to school while my youngest was in kindergarten, with the intention of returning to the workforce full-time the following year. Well, that kid just graduated from eighth grade, and I’m still sitting here. My skills are outdated, but I would be thrilled to take an entry-level position in my field. It’s a moderately growing industry, with plenty of jobs. I rarely get an interview, and even more rarely get an offer. On the rare occasion that someone does hire me, it doesn’t last. They never give me a reason that makes sense. “You’re just not the right person,” said one supervisor. “I don’t believe you really want this job,” said another, after I had been there for almost two months. I really liked that job, and had no complaints. They all seem mad at me, as though I should know why.
The last one was a light maintenance job at a big box store. And I did it with a smile. And without mentioning my college degrees. I kept my secret so well, a co-worker once whispered to me, as though I might not have guessed, “I think you’re over qualified for this job.” Really – do ya think? Again, the supervisor who fired me did it without saying why, and as though I should already know. Ok, so I have a terrible personality. But so do a lot of people, and they manage to find work.
I will admit that my social instincts are weak and that I’m not very assertive. I have been working on it for a half-century and have made significant progress. Still, I’m hard to read, and people often hallucinate around me. They tend to project their own issues onto me. Compulsive liars imagine that I’m lying with every breath…
With coworkers, the dumb ones will say it out loud, and their perceptions are enough to curl your hair. (I never said that or did it, never thought it, am shocked to hear that such a person could be imagined, let alone exist in this dimension of reality.) I am so awed by the stupidity that I can't even defend myself. I am dumbfounded, and just walk away. The smart ones keep it to themselves, and leave me to guess at the unguessable. The real me is analytical, philosophical, highly moral and slightly arrogant. And I have some background in psychology. But no one knows this. Most of my thoughts are my own, and too long-winded for any real-world situation, so I don’t say much. You want me to haul this garbage can from here to there? Fine. No discussion required. With a happy face, I aspire to be the best damn slug this company has ever had. And I still can’t get a job. My social life stinks, too, but that’s another story.
I'm going to try something different here. Something like a conversational blog, if you will. I'm going to ask others who read this to post their response on the site, and I will then post their responses here.
Bottom Line:
Through the shared thoughts of others, some good answers will hopefully come forward. Thanks to all for your joint participation in this sharing of exeriences and ideas.
Dear Doc:
I work with a female coworker who has the identical symptoms of a personality disorder such as a "narcisist". As soon as she enters the cubicle and greets me, she has to put down her hooks, of territory and artificial power. After studying counseling, including trauma, I am beginning to discern that she is unhappy inside. She has an unhealthy relationship (avoidance) with her mother, and came to our dept winning people over, before they would reject her for her obese weight, and unattractive appearance. How can I manage dealing with her low self esteem, poor sense of self, and negativity without getting burned?
Her situation is both very sad and very dangerous. She's probably unaware of how troubled she is, for that would take years of therapy. She is likely the victim of some forms of childhood abuse. Try to look beyond her obvious defense system of being difficult. These people are completely prickly until you break through their walls. Then they are a broken child inside, who wants to be loved and accepted.
Bottom Line:
Unfortunately, the vast majority of these people never get help, and provide a lifetime of hell to those around them.
Dear Doc:
My boyfriend has an ex wife who is an abusive alcoholic. She lives in the house, and he lives with me and his son. She lives in the family residence and he refuses to cut ties with her. He has so many excuses as to why he can't sell his house. He pays all the bills and gives her $600.00 a month. She is also included on his family cell phone plan. He has been living with me for 9 months and has done nothing to move foward. What should I do?
Assuming it is bothering you, it sounds like it's time to draw a line in the sand.
Bottom Line:
But if you give him an ultimatum, you need to be ready to send him backing. Just know that there are other fish in the sea, and that you probably deserve better than what you are getting right now.
Dear Doc:
Why do people have to tell other things that they promise not to tell?
Very FEW people can truly keep a secret. People LOVE to have the inside scoop on a juicy tidbit of gossip, and they LOVE the power they feel at being the one who can spill the story to someone else.
Bottom Line:
So be very careful what you say to whom. That's why some people go to a shrink. The money they pay for the service should guarantee that the doctor will keep their secrets private, for the doctor knows that they can be sued if they spill the beans.
Dear Doc:
when my granddaughter was 6yrs old (now 7) my daughter abandoned her to a father who had moved away from them when the child was 5. he took an out of state job but remained in distant contact. my daughter is a prescription drug addict so she was not the best of parent. my husband and i had the child more than her parents had her. now she is over 700 miles from us. i know she misses us and we see her as much as we can but it is not enough. anyway, my question is will she suffer from maternal abandonment? according to her father she has started to lie a lot. is this normal for a 7yr old? to punish her all of her toys are locked in a closet. is this a healthy way to punish her? thank you for considering my questions.
Yes, the absence of a maternal figure will harm her. Her lieing is probably a way that she is acting out the pain she feels from being away from you. No, that form of punishment will do little to help, because it does not speak to her underlying issue of losing you.
Bottom Line:
It may not be possible, but the more time she has with you, the more it will help her.
Dear Doc:
Hi. i am writing back to your last response about my over-controlling parents.Yes i still do live with my parents but i am not able to move out and afford it financially. i do not yet have a working permit yet i still do jobs here and there whenever i can...yet it is still not enough to support myself. Today i went solo with my bf after church...as soon as my brother got back from church they called up 5 times on my bf cellphone i did not answer. We decided to go out to lunch then over to my parents house again. As soon as we left to go to my bfs parents house to watch some movies. My mom followed us and demanded i go home with her. They have threatened to kick me out. I do not know what else i can do about this situation. Is there any other suggestions besides moving out? Please help. Is there anything wrong with them psychologically?
I wonder where you live, and what religion your family practices, because yours sounds like an overly conservative world. You need to begin today to become more independent, so that you can make your own life decisions. Get your own money so that you can make your own life. Based on where you live, your parents behavior could be viewed as normal or super unhealthy. Ultimately you are going to have to call your parents bluff, regarding kicking you out. If they will not let you be a normal dating adult, then you might be better off living poorer yet happier with your deserved independence.
Bottom Line:
I wonder if they are trying to drive your boyfriend away. Most guys would not want to date a girl who had parents that were so controlling and oppressive.
Dear Doc:
I am writing to you because i have a problem with my parents. i have been dating my bf for about 1 1/2 years already. In the beginning my parents would not let us leave at all to events,shopping or even to the park,basically anywhere, unless my siblings came along. At first i accepted it because it was my only way of leaving anywhere... but now it is starting to get sooo much on my nerves. they are soo stubborn and nothing i say to them about letting me have my privacy with my bf works. Now my little sister is soo used to us taking her everywhere that she encourages them to make us take her. I still get stuck having to bring along my siblings, a lot of the time everywhere i go. On times that i do not take them with me they(my parents) accuse me of not wanting them to go because i wanted to "find a way of sleeping with my bf" and that that would be the only reason i would want to be alone with him. The thing is i believe in waiting till marriage to have sexual relations. It really hurts me that they think that of me and it is causing a lot stress between us. I cannot leave anywhere without arguing with them. They cannot understand that i am 20 already. How should i confront this situation? They don't seem to understand that it gets annoying having them(my siblings) come along sooo many times.
You're 20?? That's nuts! What kind of power do they have over you? You must live with them. Do they support you completely?
Bottom Line:
You need to set a boundary with them, and tell them that you will be going solo with your boyfriend from now on. If they kick you out, then you need to start to support yourself, becaue they are WAY too over-controlling. My god, there are a lot of young people who are MARRIED by the time they are 20!
Dear Doc:
I have a question about your response to my letter yesterday. Are you saying that I should give up and file for a divorce if I'm not willing to live separately from now on? Because I'm not---it's just the only choice for right now. He's been in therapy for almost two months, and he keeps saying that if I'll just give him time to get straightened out, he wants to come back home. How much time should I give him? He's more screwed up than I was when I first started going to counselling; and it took me about 4-6 months to get to a much healthier place. But if there's no hope, it's just a waste of more time. That's part of the reason I asked about sex. As much as I enjoy making love with him, aren't I making myself more vulnerable to being hurt again? I honestly don't know what to do. If there's no possibility of change, why do people go to treatment? I know how much therapy helped me, and I guess I've just been hoping the same thing could happen for him. It probably sounds like I just want you to tell me what I want to hear; and maybe part of me does. But mostly I want to know why you think real change is so unlikely. I realize I'm the only one who can make this decision; and I'm going to have to live with it for the rest of my life. I want to make the wisest choice I can.
Therapy for two months is a good start, but he needs years of therapy, and probably a support system like AA for years to come, if he is to change over the long haul. I'm not trying to be negative about change, it's just that I know from 35 years as a therapist that statistically, people in his situation fail more often than not, in the long run. We all want him to succeed. The key is his resolve. If he is more determined than he has ever been about anything in his life, to make positive changes, than his chances for success go up.
Bottom Line:
There's always hope. You know, you could always divorce him and remarry if he gets healthy over time. The key would be if you cut off sex and filed for divorce. If he continues to change for the better even after that, then you know that he is changing for him, and not for you. For you see, if he's changing only to keep you, his odds of success go way down. Either way, you're going to be ok! Go in any direction, rather than doing nothing, and you will learn and grow from the journey. Good luck!
Dear Doc:
My husband and I were high school sweethearts and have been married almost 32 years. We are both 50 and have both been suffering from his midlife crisis for about 10 years now. During that time he has repeatedly been unfaithful to me and has now become an alcoholic. I still love him very much and despite how ridiculous it sounds, I believe he still loves me. He has always told me that he wants me and our marriage very much; and he is in weekly counselling to try to deal with his problems. My question for you is whether it is healthy for us to be continuing our sexual relationship during this time when we are not living together. We have always had great sex. That has never been our problem. He is still drinking but swears he is being faithful to me now. Of course I really don't know if I can believe him since he's lied to me about it for years. His counsellor says he's not ready for marriage counselling because it wouldn't do any good until he deals with his drinking problem. She says that's the main issue between us. We are getting along really well since he started therapy and are closer than we've been in a long time. Of course we're not trying to live together either. I didn't mention it before but I also have been in counselling for over two years and feel I am healthier and happier than I was before we started having problems. I earn plenty of money and have come to realize that I will be fine whether or not our marriage survives; I just want to give it every chance I can. We see each other several times a week and have sex at least once a week. Am I enabling him to continue his self-destructive behavior by trying to stay connected to him? He's always on his best behavior with me. What do you think?
Being sexual with each other is not a problem. You are not responsible for his behavior, and withholding sex probably won't change his actions.
Bottom Line:
If you're happy this way, continue. Some married couples lives separately for decades and like it. If not, get a divorce and move on, but don't sit around waiting for him to change. It's not a good bet.
Dear Doc:
SHE IS MANIC DEPRESSIVE- ON DISABILITY 63 AND DOESNT WANT HELP--I AM DONE, SPENT, ANGRY, LONELY AND TIRED. I WANT OUT---BUT SHE IS ILL AND NO FAULT OF HER OWN. AM I STUCK OR WHAT? CRAZY CRAIG
She may not have chosen her illness, but she can choose her healing. Therapy and meds can make both of your lives much better.
Bottom Line:
You are not stuck. Leave. If she wants you to stay, she will get help.
Dear Doc:
I have a thousand and some odd questions that I can't seem to find any answers too. First off, a little about me. I am the type of person who takes her responsibilities in life seriously--meaning I don't slack them off on someone else or mooch off other people. I have high moral values: honesty, integrity, and the like. I have had a difficult life to say the least, but have always kept a good attitude and been optimistic. I am not the type to want a pity party, life happens, you deal with it best as you can and you move on; and if you are lucky, you can help someone else going through something similar and be their support. Ok, here I go....For the last 9 years I was married to a man I was in love with. He was extremely emotionally and mentally abusive; as was his family. Everything was always, my fault in some way. I was paying bills and we were doing well, and he started taking huge amounts of money to "play" with. I was still left with the responsibility of paying the bills. (If I didn't they wouldn't get paid). After a while we started going without neccessary items, especially me (bras, pads, food, heat, etc). It was blamed on me time and time again. I was told to be more submissive and that the man was to be the financial descion maker. I tried letting him do the bills and months later when we were in extremely dire circumstances I took over again and got us nearly out of debt. This see-saw went on for a long time at least 7 of the years we were married. In 2004 I had told my husband I couldn't continue to live this way and begged for us to go to counseling. I continued to hold on; especially since I had no support. His family would jump from one side of the fence to the other to protect him and constantly contradict what they said previously. In 2005, I had my fifth child and my mother committed suicide within that week. Husband told me not to worry he would take care of everything so I could just take care of kids and grieve. Stupid I know, but I thought maybe he was finally starting to grow up and be responsible. Two months later everything was getting shut off due to him not paying bills. I did my best to deal with the mess he created, but after years of making deals with companies to pay they no longer trusted we would do so--And I don't blame them. My husband of course thought they were all horrible people and didn't comprehend the idea that you have to pay your bills and those people also have bills. A year after my mother's suicide his family started in on me worse than ever and the one person I had in my corner decided I was in the wrong and went off on me being a horrible wife and on and on. Something triggered and I had an "episode" of sorts. I was put on meds and faithfully took them. Recently I moved a state away from my husband and his family. During this time he stopped my medical insurance coverage and I could not afford my pills. I faithfully took them for over a year and a half. The only time I got immensly better was when my husband was removed from the home....anywho...I couldn't buy my meds, I tried to get help from the community and found none. I had about a weeks worth of cymbalta left and the mood stabilizer so I weaned myself off slowly hoping the withdrawal effects wouldn't be so severe. Please understand, I would've taken the meds for life since I have children, period. The circumstances mad it impossible to do so. I have been off the meds for almost two months now and I am not having any symptoms or signs of bipolar. I have told numberous people in the church, neighbors, support group so they are aware in case I have an "episode" and can get me help. However, I am back to being the "me" I was ten years ago before I married my husband. My Vocational Rehabilitation counselor wonders if I had Post Tramdic Stress (considering my background of being abused from a young age on). In 2005, I did have a psychotic episode...it seemed like I was drugged up...it was dream like...I went through 3 days of hell and never want to repeat that...another reason I wouldn't have gone off meds. I am full of questions...if I have bipolar I, according to the nurse practitioner I was seeing in the other state...it would be obvious I was off my meds within 3 days. Is it possible I am not bipolar? Is it possible that the stress and abuse I endured for so long and without a support of any kind cause a nervous breakdown? I am confused as to why I am doing so well. Don't get me wrong I love it! It is nice to feel normal again, and not have irrational fear and anxiety. My moods are stable, my stress is fairly low. I do plan on getting into counseling just so I have someone professional that can back me up on being fine...and to watch in case I do have an episode. I have been going through a christian based 12 step program that has helped me a lot as well....I realize that I could have stopped it long ago and left. Unfortunately, him and his family knew my faithfulness to my faith and played it against me; however, I had the power to stop it. Mainly, I am tring to figure out what happened to me. My few friends I had during my marriage have studied bipolar with me and they say they have never seen any of these symptoms in me. I have a huge support group now and none of them see any symptoms either, (there are a few that work with bipolar people regularly). I want to stay healthy and I do not want another episode as it was horrible. Unlike most of the bipolar people I know...I remember everything during those 3 days clearly and it was scary and made no sense--yet at the time in my mental state it all made perfect sense. Do you have any ideas on this that I can check into? Is it possible that removing myself from the stressful situation was all I needed? I don't deny I have issues...the biggest one being I don't seem to know how to make boundaries--and when I do make them, I tend to let others guilt trip me for it--which in turn causes me to remove the line in the sand, so to speak. I just want to ensure I get the right help for the right problem as well...LOL. Sorry to have gone on so long, I appreciate any insight you could give me on this.
You are correct that yours would be a much better world if you started to develop healthy boundaries.
Bottom Line:
If it's not too late, change your whole world now, and certainly take the medications that a competent Doctor prescribes for you.
Dear Doc:
hi, i've been dating my bf for a little over a year. Right now i am realizing an annoying habit of his and i don't know how to tell him about it. Most of the time he does not like to admit he's wrong, or even though he does try...it is hard for him to listen and understand on certain things. What i am realizing is that my bf has a terrible habit of lying. I notice he gets into this mood after we get in small arguments. They are not big lies like he's cheating on me or anything... they are just small obvious lies and when i correct him and say that's not true he denies it. i don't know if he's lying intentionally or not. i don't know why he would have to lie about small things intentionally; they are no big deal. This habit of his is leading me to not believing him on many things. When i hear him telling me things he sounds sooo convinced on what hes saying that i often hold back on correcting him. How can i talk to him about this without him getting offended and come back at me with saying " your calling me a liar!".
Your relationship sounds very sketchy. You're calling him a liar because he is one. You shouldn't have to sugar-coat that. Talk to him straight up. If he can't handle it, then you need to break up and move on asap!
Bottom Line:
You are letting him get away with unhealthy behavior, and you are not acting as his equal. That's a formula for disaster down the road for sure!
Dear Doc:
I JUST HAVE ONE QUESTION. I AM A VERY ATTRACTIVE WOMAN AND STILL IN LOVE WITH MY EX-BOYFRIEND. HE KNOWS THIS AND I JUST Saw HIM TWO DAYS IN A ROW WITH THIS NEW GIRLFRIEND, AND SHE IS NOT ATTRACTIVE. HE IS VERY PICKY ABOUT LOOKS, AND I JUST WANT TO KNOW WHY HE WOULD BE WITH SOMEONE LESS ATTRACTIVE THAN ME.
First of all, you need to learn to not write everything in caps. It turns most people off. With regard to your question, personal appearance is only the first thing that brings people together. After that, it is who they are on the inside that keeps them together.
Bottom Line:
Attractiveness is subjective, so maybe she is attractive to him. Plus she may bring a lot of other benefits to the relationship, which he has decided are more important than external appearances.
Dear Doc:
My ex-boyfriend pled to assault and battery for spitting on me and he's ordered to do no contact from me for a year and to get a mental health evaluation. I have been able to be strong enough not talk to him for about three and a half months so far, because I moved, changed numbers, and now also changed my job, because he had worked there too. I am in domestic violence counseling since I have a history of past abuse as well. I got a new job that is interesting and financially better than the last job, despite all my stress from this. About two weeks ago, my former boss called to warn me that he got fired, for outbursts at work. His coworker emailed me that he had a "mental collapse" at work. In the past, he blamed me for things, including wanting to kill himself, and he had acted out at me at work in the lobby. In between raging, he was an apparently nice, charming, charismatic, attractive man. I had real trouble doing no contact until I changed jobs because he and I worked at the same place. Also, before I changed jobs, the company gave him a warning for leaving a message on my work voice mail, telling me I had better call him or else he'd make sure I'd pay (think he meant pay him money because he said he'd sue me for an Internet posting). I seem to be having trouble all over again, since my former boss called me, being worried about HIM, now that he's fired. Even now, three months later, I seem to have trouble accepting that he is mentally ill, not getting any help, or else not explaining his actual behavior to the counselor when I did get him to go. I still have feelings for him and care about what happens to him, although I have managed not to contact him so far in light of the order, etc. I think he has borderline personality disorder, although is very high functioning. How can I ever emotionally accept that he is not changing, not getting help, even now? He wrote things on the Internet blaming the company for firing him and saying he would sue the company, etc., not taking responsibility. Also, he wrote that he is moving out of state due to his firing. My minister who helped me through all this has advised me not to contact my ex to see if he is okay since his firing, since he'd be angry and possibly dangerous. Plus, I'd have to change my numbers all over again, because he always asked for them, was nice for a while, but would then would rage at me until I had to change them (4 times). I was doing much better until I heard he got fired. I think I also feel guilty for reporting his message at work, which also contributed to him being fired (the warning). I guess I don't understand how to stop caring what happens to him. It's hard because I still remember when he acted "normal" and I know rationally he is just sick. Also, how do I not feel guilty because my reporting his behavior got him a warning, which laid the foundation for him being fired? Now he doesn't have health insurance and can't get help. Lastly, do some people just go through life, blind to the fact that they need help? I really tried to get him help but he said the counselors were entertained by his stories but did not help him at all. I sort of feel like I "drove him crazy" somehow. When I met him he was on anti-depressants, though, from a previous breakup.
You need to avoid him like the plague. It is absolutely true that some people never get better. This is the type of person who ends up on the evening news, after the police are called because of domestic violence.
Bottom Line:
You need to see your own ill-health in this situation. Get into some good therapy, where you can dump your unhealthy guilt. You were powerless to make him as sick as he is, and you are even more powerless to help him. Being a rescuer would be one of the most unhealthy things you could do (and it's guaranteed to fail).
Dear Doc:
why does my boyfriend get mad when i don't answer his call and leaves me messages like "i know you are up to something, i know how you are"?
Because insecurity is very ugly.
Bottom Line:
This is NOT a good sign. Jealousy kills many relationships. You may want to consider a life without him, for your long term sanity.
Dear Doc:
My 19 yo daughter is in over head and I'm fearing she may need some type of inpatient treatment to snap out of it. She has always been troubled, no matter how hard her father and I try to help her. Last year she finally seemed to break through, and was doing great with her studies and socially it seemed. Then near the end of her junior year of HS (we kept her back in kindergarten), she said she was raped by one of the most popular boys in the school. I totally believe her and stood by her, her father thinks it's another one of her stories. Well, because she didn't go right to the police there wasn't enough to prosecute him with. She went back to school for one day and was tormented, because the other kids said she was a liar. Since then a lot has happened and she is now living who knows where, she says with friends, but won't tells us where she is. She moved by her own choice, and I'm still not sure why she moved out. I'm so afraid she is going to end up hurt or worse. The thing that really troubles me about her is, she is a compulsive liar. I've never seen anything like it, she makes up all these horrible stories about her life. She tells other people things have happened to her that never have. She even told someone she had a chlid when she was 13, that was the result of her fathers molestation. Which, believe me is a complete fabrication. Is this a mental problem? I stand by her and believe her when she is hurting, my husband doesn't. He says everything is a lie, he doesn't even know about what she said about him and the child. If I get her to sign herself in for inpatient psychiatric help, will this help her. Do you recommend any particular type Tx center? Please help before she is gone forever!! A Loving Mother
Yes, compulsive lieing can be defined as a mental health disorder. As you may know, once a child is 18, they can sign themselves out of the hospital, unless the authorities determine that she is suicidal, homicidal, or cannot function on her own. So, if she will stay in the hospital, they can possibly help her, but only if she wants to change. Unless she is covered by a health insurance plan, these programs are very very expensive.
Bottom Line:
This type of situation can be hell for you as the parent, because it is obvious to you that something is wrong, but you are powerless to do much about it. The biggest hope will be if she asks for help, and is serious about making some self improvements.
Dear Doc:
Hello, I have an adult son who began using drugs at about age twenty-five. He also had O.C.D..(Obsessive Compulsive Disorder). He was a sickly child, and had health problems into adulthood. I believe that he began using drugs, in order to escape the demons in his head. I remember him telling me once,"somtimes I cannot turn off the terrible thoughts my brain has going on. I often imagine TERRIBLE images in my mind, and cannot turn them off." Is it possible that the drug use was an attempt to quiet the scary thoughts?
Absolutely. It is sometimes referred to as "street medicating". The person aches for relief, so they use substances that are available on the street to ease their pain. They often are not even conscious that they are doing this. This is a VERY common practice, in that many use alcohol, marijuana, etc. to get the job done.
Bottom Line:
The better alternative is to go to a Psychiatrist that he can be honest with, and whom he trusts. That person will then prescribe to him safer and more effective medicines that will help slay his demons. There are currently some very effective OCD medicines on the market.
Dear Doc:
After being in my step son's life for the past five years, why would my step son tell his mom that i spanked him with the belt? I don't even punish my other two children; my husband is the primary punisher. I do however take things away when the kids mis-behave (ex: Playstation). How do i get my stepson's mom to see that i would never hit a child?
You can't get her to change her mind if she doesn't want to. Continue to be a good person, and hopefully his mom will admit to your decency one day. Speak with her if she's willing, but realize that she may have a dysfunctional vested self-interest in viewing you as a bad person (e.g., it makes her feel better about her own poor behavior).
Bottom Line:
I wonder how old your step-son is. People do things for a reason, so he must have had a goal in mind (be it conscious or not), when he told that to his mom. Rise above it all, and you will find a calm in the long run.
Dear Doc:
why after 16 years of marriage & then 15 years of being divorced, & we are both remarried to some one else, why is she so bent on destroying me still? She's the one that cheated & she is the one who filed for the divorce in January 1992.
Some people are unhappy for life, and they want to (often unconsciously) take everyone down with them.
Bottom Line:
Be happy that you are away from this toxic person. Do everything you can to stay out of touch with her.
Dear Doc:
I called my ex to see why he hasn't called our son. He got very angry with me. Like always, it's my fault. I usually get mad and hang up. Im really getting sick of being blamed for his pride problems or whatever it may be. Please help me to defuse the situation for my son's sake.
Don't call him again. Unfortunately, you cannot save your son from dad's misbehavior.
Bottom Line:
Explain to your son that there is nothing you can do. Encourage your son to contact him if he wants to see his dad. If dad continues the non-contact, your son will learn which parent is there for him, and which one is a flake. A hard but valuable life-changing lesson.
Dear Doc:
I've read your reply to another wondering if her spouse could be gay and respect your advice and opinion. I'm troubled by the same dilemma. My scenario is incredibly close to the Brokeback Mountain movie. It's not a matter of seeing how life imitates art; instead it's a worrisome coincidence that sends me chills.
My spouse is sensitive which I appreciate, but more effeminate than masculine. Our sex-life is sporadic; the pattern is weeks without activity and then one literal honey-moon week after I express my frustration. He feels I have an unusually high drive, while I feel his interest is far lower than my past relationship partners.
He enjoys frequent hunting and fishing trips. Right now he is on his way home from a trip and of course he hasn't caught anything. Before he left he told me about how wimpy his fishing buddy is and that last time the guy kept asking him if he was cold or if he should come into the bedroom quarters (instead of the couch). Talk about Brokeback (and my partner hasn't seen the movie either). Then yesterday in our 4 minute, touch-base-call, wouldn't you know a joke about this same friend "coming on to him all night" was said. He told me the fished the night before, but later stated the boat wasn't set up yet (?). Before he left he talked about how much he used to enjoy nudity when he lived on his own and told me of a time he answered the door naked when his friend visited. I thought this sounded like unusual behaviour. Others in his life wondered if he was gay before. He said he isn't. I've tried to help him communicate on these issues in gentle and direct ways, but without any real responses. I explained how most men I know have had others come on to them, same-sex fantasies are normal, etc. One time when we were looking at pornography he seemed especially interested in transexuals and told me if I'm good, he'll get me one for my birthday. I joked, "is that one of those presents you really want but get for someone else?" Then I tried more direct approaches, and stated some observations--still nothing. I still love him, but do worry I can not compete with male interests if they exist. I sense he would not reveal anything new in counselling, or dealing with this issue could hurt him. For now, I wonder if what I've described sounds like there is a good possibility he is bi-sexual. Sincerely, Curious if he's bi-sexually curious.
A posibility indeed.
Bottom Line:
Keep your eyes and ears open. If you discover definitive proof, then you can directly speak with him about the possibilities regarding your future together.
Dear Doc:
My 14 y/o daughter seems to have the hardest time adjusting to coming back home after visiting her father for 3days during school & 9 weeks during the summer. He lives 2 states away. I have primary px. custody yet she seems to think of him as the "good parent" tho he provides very little to her support month-to-month, year-to-year, etc. How can I look better in her eyes...I provide so much more for her incl. instilling good morals, values & principles. I'm beginning to feel like a failure yet I know that if whe were to live with him in New Orleans, these things might vanish. What should I do?
It's hard, but be patient. There is no way that you are a failure.
Bottom Line:
The "fun" or "good" parent is usually found out as the child grows up. As you continue to be there for her over the years, she should come to realize your great value over time. This may take until she is an adult, but she will get there.
Dear Doc:
I HAVE BEEN MARRIED FOR 10 YEARS AND 2 LOVELY GIRLS AGED 5 AND 8. HUSBAND HAD A WEDLOCK CHILD BUT SHE WAS NEVER PART OF OUR LIVES OR HIS. NOW SHE WANTS TO SEE HIM. SHE IS 14 YEARS OF AGE. HE DOES NOT KNOW HER AT ALL, BUT I DO NOT WANT TO TELL MY KIDS ABOUT HER. THEY ARE STILL TO YOUNG. WHAT DO I DO? NEED HELP. ITS KILLING ME. THE HOUSEHOLD IS NOT THE SAME ANY MORE. A LOT OF TENTION BETWEEN ME AND MY HUSBAND.
If he want to see her, that's the right thing to do.
Bottom Line:
It will surely be complicated, but your younger girls can view her as a positive rather than a negative, if you present it in that light.
Dear Doc:
my husband is a recovering alcoholic--we are currently separated--his personality and physical appearance has dramatically changed for the good--he is polite, engaging, involved--i do think that he may be a narcissist--a bit manipulating and controlling. how can i tell--can i still be happy with him?
Proceed with great caution. Unfortunately, the odds of a relapse are great.
Bottom Line:
You have to set clear boundaries with this type of person. Statistically, the chances for long term happiness with him are slim. Anything is possible, but you would do well to keep your life-choice options flexible.
Dear Doc:
I antagonized my boyfriend by trying to get him to see me more, even though I know all the things going in his life are preventing him from doing so. I really gave him a hard time this weekend and I regret it because I drove him away and I didn't mean to. I appologized and told him that I was too focused on not appreciating the time that I did spend with him; instead, I focused on the times we didn't spend together. I wish I understood men more; we got along so well and I feel so aweful because he didn't deserve my badgering, he is too sweet.
In the long run it never works to try to require or force a person to be with you. It's usually the kiss of death to a relationship.
Bottom Line:
If he doesn't want to be with you, go out and have fun with yourself. Maybe then he'll realize how great you are, and will start to want to spend more time with you. If he doesn't, then move on, because waiting around forever is a waste of your time, and you can do better!
Dear Doc:
I am a twenty year old girl and I'm currently in college. I have a twenty-five year old boyfriend who I've been dating for over a year. At the end of this school year I would like to possibly move in with him. It would save us both money and I already stay at his apartment half of the time anyways. The problem is, my parents are very old-fashioned and conservative. They do not believe in sex before marriage or living together before marriage. My parents love my boyfriend and I wouldn't want to do anything to change the way they feel about him or our relationship. What should I do? Thanks.
You are not in charge of how your parents feel about your boyfriend. Your parents are in denial, as you have been living part-time with him in a sexual relationship for quite some time already. Look at it this way: maybe you will do them a favor in the long run by pushing them to consider new ideas. They won't like it at first, but that doesn't mean it isn't good for them.
Bottom Line:
It is healthiest to be true to yourself, and live your life as you see fit. If you compromise who you are for others, you are creating a slow death for yourself. Not a good idea.
Dear Doc:
my daughter just turned 16 and is pregnant. her "boyfriend" just had a baby 2 weeks ago. my husband and i are 34 and have 4 kids of our own and raising my niece and nephew, a total of 6 kids, and are not ready to raise another one. my husband wants her to have an abortion or have her emmancipated. i dont know what to do. please help.
Maybe adoption would be a reasonable choice. Your daughter has created her own problem. Her adult choice to become pregnant must be followed by her adult choice as to what to do now. For you to rescue her would be to deprive her of the opportunity to learn the consequences of her actions (one of life's most important lessons).
Bottom Line:
It seems true that your family is full to the brink already, and that to take on another child would probably sink the entire ship. Not a good idea.
Dear Doc:
I'm so lonely and just want to cry all the time, so I do. I keep having flashbacks of my exhusband treating me poorly and wanting me to feel bad about myself. I'm angry at all the mean and horrible things people have done to me in the past because I actually thought that it was ok for them to treat me this way. When I look back i'm enraged.
So far so good. This is the first step in your recovery.
Bottom Line:
Now you need to not get stuck feeling like a victim. Do something positive for yourself by going forward in your life. Without hope we are dead, so believe that you are now empowered to bring good into your world. It really is true!
Dear Doc:
My boyfriend and I (lived together eight years) have been seperated for one year. I was the one who called it quits. He has dated a fair amount this past year. Last month, we started seeing each other again and last night we spoke hypothetically about rekindling our romance. Is it appropriate or desirable for me to call him? Or should I treat this as a formal courtship and wait for him to call the shots? If I want to get back together, how do I ensure that we succeed and that I get what I want and am able to fulfill his needs, too?
There is no reason why you shouldn't call him.
Bottom Line:
Obviously, there are never any guarantees, but if you both are truly honest about your needs going forward, you will have your best chance for success.
Dear Doc:
I am very unhappy, our marriage has been on an unpersonal level for the last 15 yrs, I fell like a maid or housekeeper, I get little respect, all the quizzes I have taken I am considered emotionally and verbally abused, my husand is a past Alcohlic and drug abuser but has been dry for years,I am a nurse but due to back injury have been unable to work since 1995. Material things I have not lacked for within reason. We just do not seem to have anything in common or like the same things since the kids grew up. He does things like get another dog I did not want which I take care of most of time or it would be neglected, then makes me feel guilty when I don't want him. I had a difficult dhildhood, my self esteem is bad to start with and grew up poor and do not want to live that way again. We do travel 4 months out of yr which I enjoy and he is like a different person. I do not converse often with him as anything I say or do seems to make him angry, like if I talk about plans for future, he then gives me the I am never satisfied routine, so I have jus learned to bottle things up, and that makes him mad that i do not visit. We live in a small community of 350 so there is not much to do here and I don't enjoy living here but our house is paid for and they are not worth anything here, so selling out and starting over in a larger place would cause a mortgage and his health is worse than mine and I can't afford a big mortgage as at least 50% of his income I would loose if he died, he spends money on all the sports things he likes and traveling but complains everytime I want to upkeep the house or move the laundry room up to make it easier on my back and walking as I fall and it is happening more often. I just am so unhappy I rarely smile or have lost interest in any of the artistic things I used to do, I just seem to cook, clean, wash clothes, take care of the dogs and others. Would I be better off alone? Is there any question tests to take to help me decide or point me in right direction?
You don't need to take any more tests. Your situation is pretty obvious... you are a member of the miserably married club (which is, unfortunately, a very large club).
Bottom Line:
It sounds like changing your world would be very very difficult. Assuming that you are not up for that, it looks like you need to make the best of your current circumstance by finding a life beyond your husband. All you can change is you, but if you change for the better, maybe that will bring some good out of him. Above all else, don't wait for him to make you happy, because that never works.
Dear Doc:
I once again got emotionally hooked into a relationship with my abusive ex-boyfriend who works at the same place I do. I had been in counseling a year and a half and just switched to domestic violence counseling which seems more helpful. The last thing that happened is that he held me down, told me not to leave his apartment, and spit several times in my eyes, on my face, and on my work clothes. I had brought him a biscuit sandwhich and he threw it at me, and spread it on the carpet and said you did this, it is your fault, clean it up. I reported this to the police and I think he is charged with assault and battery. I know they served a warrant.
He also yelled at me in the lobby at work and we both had to talk to HR and security, accusing ME of threatening HIM. I have been trying to find a new job and so far have no luck. He looks at pornography and is mesmerized by pictures of young women with men spraying semen on their faces. I told him I did not like this and in the last couple weeks, he held me down and did that to me. Because of the police situation, I am not talking to him. Also, my pastor says he could kill me because he said he felt like killing himself because of me and I ruined his life. I was debating whether to take sick leave from work but so far am functioning as I can work elsewhere up to 3 days a week sometimes. I am just discouraged as my ex-husband punched me and my Dad physically and emotionally abused me and I keep repeating the same stupid patterns. What else can I do? I'm in domestic violence counseling and three online support groups. I just feel very powerless to report to that office building not knowing if he is in an elevator I'm walking into.
Your pastor is right. You've got to get away from him to save your life. Take the police report to your work, to prove that you can't be around him. Get a restraining order against him. Change jobs and move out of town if you have to, to ensure that you are away from him. Unfortunately, as the old song says, you are looking for love in all the wrong places.
Bottom Line:
Don't give up on your therapy. If need be, find better people to help you. But in the end, it's up to you to protect yourself and start your better life over, away from this eminent danger.
Dear Doc:
I'm always attracting guys who want to dominate me, or control me in some way. Why might this be? I want to find love, real love and don't even know what this really means. I love myself, I finally accept who I am, but still have not met anyone.
Unfortunately there are a lot of not-too-healthy guys out there (and ladies too)!
Bottom Line:
As you love and like yourself more, you'll need outside love less, which is when a healthy male version of it will most certainly appear. If we want it too much it alludes us. If we are content in ourselves and fine whether it comes or goes, by golly but here it comes. One of life's many great paradoxes.
Dear Doc:
Something simple. My ex girlfriend had suddenly been consumed with caring for her sick uncle and taking care of her mother's chores over a period of 3 months. Our time together had been dwindling. I would question it and all she would say was that she's never been so busy before in her life. Short of the story is that she told me "I knew you wouldn't wait" (what is that supposed to mean?) The other thing was I asked her if she wanted me out of her life and she said yes. I can't stand the ups and downs any more (recently being diagnosed bi-polar). What do you think?
I think you are better off to move on and not look back.
Bottom Line:
Those mood swings could be the death of you. Wish her well, and advance to someone who is easier to be with.
Dear Doc:
How do I get my daughter away from manipulative ex-boyfriend? She is a 17 yr old who dated an 18 yr old for a year. He cheated on her several times during this year and she finally had enough of the rumors and broke up with him. She lost her virginity to him a few months ago. He has been gone all summer and she has tried to move on with her life. He has now come back to town for the new school year and was with several girls during the summer. He now tells her that he wants her back... that he loves her. I told her that if he loved her he would not have been with girls over the summer or cheated on her. I know he is only using her and manipulating her. She tells him that she can't trust him and he tells her that she should just forget about the past and that he is trying to make things work and she is just making things hard between them. He is very manipulative and a compulsive liar. He has denied ALL of the cheating alligations and has said that everyone is just making it all up. She even talked to one of the girls that he was with and this girl confirmed that they were together. He said that that girl is also making everything up. The trouble is she believes him! We have banned her from seeing him or hanging out with him anymore which now she is mad at us and I feel that by doing this we are probably pushing her closer to him. We feel that she should be so mad at him for all of this that she hates him, but she doesn't. She says that they are going to be friends. But he won't stop at telling her he wants her back and that he loves her. When we try and tell her that he is no good she defends him. How do we get to see that he is no good? Please help!!
You are pretty powerless in this situation.
Bottom Line:
It may be wiser to get out of her way and let her learn from her mistakes.
Dear Doc:
i need to reinvent myself. i've never had a boyfriend because every guy ends up thinking im crazy. i think i get attached because i had a bad history with my father and im afraid of losing people. i get so crazily attached and then they end up thinking im crazy and that's why they don't want to be with me. what's wrong with me?
You definitely sound like you are too needy, which as you say, drives them away.
Bottom Line:
Go get some long term professional help. You need to rebuild your self esteem, which will help you become stronger and more independent. Trust me... then men will want to spend time with you over the long haul.
Dear Doc:
I've been dating a guy for 5 months that i have a great connection with. We both work a lot and both us of us love what we do. He seems like the kind of guy who is afraid to be in a relationship, he's a scientist and i'm an an artist. As i'm writing this, i see that i just have to let him go and see what happens. Why is it that men can chase women, but women can't chase men. As I write this, I finally realize he has a lot of "mommy" issues and often thinks i'm critising him when i'm not at all. I'm sad about this, because I like who he is very much, but he seems like an injured child and i'm not about to go and jump in to try and save him, that would be scary on my part. Argh, when will i meet a great guy who i feel comfortable with who is there for me. I am spending enormous amounts of time getting my life together, being healthy, hanging with my wonderful friends, but still, no man. I guess I need to stop trying.
It sounds like you are heading in the right direction.
Bottom Line:
Enjoy yourself, and your good friends. If a guy comes along, may it be the icing on the top of your cake. It's never healthy to make another person the center of who we are.
Dear Doc:
How to sum up a long story...I've been with my boyfriend for 6 years. We were engaged 2 years ago and I broke off the engagement a few months after it happened because I hadn't successfully dealt with some pain from the past. We continued to have a relationship, but as you can imagine nothing was ever the same. I sought professional help to get me over the past and I have been trying to move things forward with him for a while now. My boyfriend is still with me, but things are very strained and he is not sure that he wants to commit to a serious relationship again. In fact he says that he is confused and unsure how to get the things that he wants for the future. So, I would really appreciate some advice on how to help discover what is really in his heart and how to rekindle a strained relationship?
The truth is that you probably can't get back what the two of you once had.
Bottom Line:
It sounds like he may have been irrepairably hurt by your past. You could try going to therapy together, but you may also need to prepare yourself for the end of this relationship. A sad but possibly unavoidable truth.
Dear Doc:
My friend Grant who is 14 is going through a rough time. He just found out that his sister who is 17 drinks, smokes pot, and is bisexual. His uncles is dying because hes an acholic and i dont know what advice to give him, or how to help him.
It's great that you want to be helpful. In these situations there often aren't any easy answers.
Bottom Line:
If you can just be there for him, listening and being non-judgmental, you may help him talk himself through his struggles.
Dear Doc:
i'm often made a fool. Why might this be? I'm tall, very attractive, talented, and smart and am a target of envy. i'm usually a little too nice to people, i smile a lot. I also avoid conflict a little too much.
Continue exploring, and you will find the answer. Find an honest friend who will tell you why others make fun of you.
Bottom Line:
If need be, seek out a therapist to help you understand the underpinnings of this apparent contradiction.
Dear Doc:
I have been going thru breast cancer tx since 2003. I have many other health issues. However my toughest one and still is happens to be the man I gave my everything to. 7 yrs of building trusting, loving, forgiving , the thought of him leaving me was an issue until we went to counciling and I really worked on setting my boundaries and learning to say no. and him respecting that. He was scared when we found out I have cancer and was there but, it was almost like a duty. Well he left me almost 1 yr to then day of diagnoses. It took so much of me. my friends tell me I am not the same person. Not mean or anything but,well one friend said it's like I died inside.We broke up several times and he always was on the door step saying he could not be without me to come home. anyway heres the kicker he called me 3 months later and asked if he could see me and of course i could of said no but I wanted to touch him, he came in had a glass of wine and we started touching, hugging , crying, then he told me before we made love that he was GETTING MARRIED. (all the touching STOPPED) We still have a connection to this day and he was stopping by my job in the mall. Ha, easy access. Well I started dating and after 4 mo. this man asked me to marry him. I accepted and I called David and told him. He was silent for awhile and then his voice started shaking and he told me this was hard for him and he did not like it. He did not want to hear it and he did not think he would have felt this way. He congradulated me and hung up. Well we picked out rings and everything but , everything started moving really fast. This man started yelling and flipping (sign langage) out men that smiled while we were driving down the interstate. So my family started telling me to watch that one theres something not right. I BROKE IT OFF.... OK, SO, NOW I'M BABBLING MY QUESTION IS HOW CAN A MAN THAT I KNOW WE WERE SO COMPLETLY CONNECTED GET MARRIED WITH IN 3 MONTHS OF OUR BREAKING UP? MIND YOU HE HAS BEEN MARRIED 2X BEFORE. IT IS HARD TO LET YOU DOC, WHEN THERE'S 7 YRS. OF HISTORY HERE.
People often remarry in order to try to run away from their broken heart.
Bottom Line:
Sounds like it is best for everyone to move forward, and not look over the shoulder of the past.
Dear Doc:
I have raised my step-son for 16 years, he has recently moved out, and his girlfriend is pregnant. He does not see or want to see his biological Mom. What rights do I have for my step-grandchild? My step-son is really like my son.
You will have to contact an attorney, as the laws no doubt differ from state to state.
Bottom Line:
Hopefully your step-son will want to include you in the life of his child.
Dear Doc:
My mother-in-law does not get along with her 3 daughters, but has a good relationship with her two son's. One of her daughter's is having her first baby. What should she do? Reconnect or keep it discontinued?
If it hasn't gotten better after all these years, it's probably not going to happen now. She should move on. If her mom wants to change things, she can initiate the improvements.
Bottom Line:
The birth will be an especially important time for the daughter to protect herself from the mother's downsides. She doesn't need mom messing up her relationship with her new child!
Dear Doc:
I dated a guy I met on line for two years; met his family etc. We planned a life together. I broke the relationship off Feb 2007, because I still had no ring and felt it was a game. well... I felt lonely the other day and called his phone; he had his number changed. Was he lieing to me the entire time? Did he really care ? Sex is something he can get in his home state?
You're reading way too much into the number change. It could be as simple as him changing phone companies.
Bottom Line:
It makes little sense that all of two years would be a lie. People don't stay together that long if they don't care, and there had to be more to it than sex. It sounds like your insecurities are doing the talking right now. Tell them to shut the !@#$ up!
Dear Doc:
As a recently divorced woman getting back on the dating scene, I've been incredibly self-absorbed lately and trying to get my career going, get healthy because i was severely ill this winter and almost died. I was just told by a guy who I was actually going to break up with tonight that i'm self absorbed. I just answered "your're right" so we broke up. I don't like that he wants me to feel wrong for being really involved with what i'm doing etc. I felt like he was rushing me into something. I need my time to heal, date slowly and get my life on track and not feel wrong for doing so. It would be great to meet a guy who would understand this. Where is he? Taking my time to get to know someone seems like it's the most important thing for me right now because I'm worried that I could still be attracting the same kind of guy.
You are making the right choices. Keep it up!
Bottom Line:
Rebounding is so typical, and so unhealthy. You will be better off in the long run as you take your sweet time to get yourself right, before sharing you with another.
Dear Doc:
Why did this married man who promised to marry me leave me so heartlessly when his wife found out?
It's time to wake up and smell the coffee. This is what happens most of the time in your situation.
Bottom Line:
When it finally comes down to tearing up a family, a house, and finances, most people decide that leaving just isn't worth it.
Dear Doc:
What guidance can you give me in trying to have a civil discussion with someone that commonly uses "always" and "never" to describe their dissatisfaction with another's behavior? (e.g. you ALWAYS take his side of an arugument)
You might want to give up having a discussion with someone like this!
Bottom Line:
There are many reasons why people speak this way, and they usually point to the person's emotional ill-health. Tell them you cannot speak with them any longer if they can't find the middle ground of words like "sometimes" and "maybe". However, they probably won't change, so prepare yourself to move on from these unhealthy and wasteful discussions. There are better people out there for you to spend your time with!
Dear Doc:
What do I do about my teenage daughter who doesn't want to spend every other weekend with her father? Says she hates him, says t his to him, and if he really cared about her he wouldn't force her to stay on his weekends with the kids. (We have been separated for 6 months. She has always had anxiety about staying over night at places other than her house. I feel she needs to have a relationship with her father and spend the weekends but she is angry and upset that she is being forced. My husband feels we should not give her an option and tell her it is unfortunate she feels that way and we understand that she is hurt and angry but she has no choice and will be staying with him every other weekend, and if she chooses to just not talk and sit in the corner it is her fault. I feel she needs to talk to an outside party, someone who deals with this kind of issue. Someone to help her understand and learn to cope with her situation. That her, me and my husband should go together and seek help in this matter. My husband feels that I gave her a choice on some weekends to stay home if she felt that way and that has just hurt her more and that my way of protecting her put us back and she needs to know that this is just the way it is now and she will have to accept it and deal with it but she will be staying with him every other weekend and how she chooses to be is her problem and if she doesn't change her attitude and doesn't stop carrying on she will be punished for her disrespect. I need some serious help, I am upset my daughter is hurting and I want to help. How can I????
It will only backfire to force her. You can't legislate or require love. Let her choose, and then there is a chance for love down the long-term road.
Bottom Line:
It would be great to get with a counselor and discuss it as a threesome, but will her dad listen to what he doesn't want to hear?
Dear Doc:
my sister had some issues with an abusive boyfriend and my mother took guardianship of her two children almost a year ago. since then my sister has had a very difficult time getting her children back. she is fighting her all the way. she has since gotten her life in order but she still refuses to give her children back. she is also doing things like "playing" them against their mother and telling them that she is not their mom. we all know this is damaging to the chilren more then anyone. what should she do, because she is also concerned about hurting my mother and does not have the finances to continue the battle.
The last thing she should worry about is hurting her mother. Without money, she will probably lose, because these battles are almost always won or lost in the courtroom.
Bottom Line:
Maybe she can find a public funding source to help her to fight for her kids, but be prepared for a battle that can go on for years.
Dear Doc:
i have such a toxic family. I'm in my early thirties, I am successful and on the verve of becoming extremely sucessful, but my father doubts me to my whole family behind my back. I'm so sad, I feel so betrayed. He is a "good guy" to me in person and on the phone and then I found this out yesterday. My family is always playing each other against each other, creating triangles, especially with money. I've moved away, been divorced (surprise, surprise, i married and divorced a wolf in sheeps clothing) I'm in therapy, but i'm still always disappointed by them, but I guess I realize they won't change. It is just sad. I really love what I do, my father never followed his dreams and he doubted me all through school. My new success is a world class success that i'm sure he could never see for himself, but i guess i have to realize that my family can not see much past themselves. It's just very lonely now to be divorced, have an unreliable and more an untrustworthly one. But the silver lining in all this is that I have amazing friends of all ages.
Some families just don't get healthier.
Bottom Line:
So you have to move one, and enjoy those friends, who are the family you choose, rather than the family that was foisted upon you at birth!
Dear Doc:
My boyfriend of three years is soon to be moving home which is about a 4 hour drive from where I live. For the past three years we have practically lived in each others pockets and weekends apart were tough on both of us. Any previous attempts at long distance has ended badly. Neither of us talk naturally on the phone and we dont communicate well long distance which has lead to fights. do you have any tips on how to build long distance communication skills? or how to broach the subject with my boyfriend? Thanks.
Can you live near him?
Bottom Line:
Short of that, you had better have a direct discussion about it asap, or else the relationship probably won't make it.
Dear Doc:
i am 20yr old girl,am studying in abroad.i was brave and studious when i was with my parents,but now i don't think so.because these days am distracted lot.i was friendly to a guy,and i was concern regarding his health since he has congenital defect in his heart.and also he is 18 months younger to me...but later on it developed to love .i can't be without him and he can't live without me.the problem i have is we both are from different caste and my parents won't agree for our marrige.and i don't want to hurt my parents feelings,since i respect them.so am thinking a lot about this and i couldn't concentrate in my studies.so plz help me out of this problem.
Difficult indeed. Assuming you don't want to change everything with your family and their traditions, you'll have to let this relationship go.
Bottom Line:
On the other hand, a lot of society's rules are unnecessary, and hold people back. If you can go against the tide, stay with him and build a new and freer world for both of you.
Dear Doc:
i am 20yr old girl,madly,truly,deeply in love with a 25 yr old...we are dating for 2yrs nw and we have plans of marriage in 2010...the problem is i am residing in kolkata n my boyfriend is leaving for mumbai next week...a 2yr programme...plz tell me how shall i cope up with this...i cant live without him for a second n i am studying here n cant leave kolkata n neither can we marry now!!!I AM VERY DEPRESSED!!! n i trust him bt i dnt trust the girls in mumbai...am insecure for that too...n moreso how shall i impress his mother...she just cant tolerate me...she shows her son she loves me but i fight...i just want my boyfriend to think i am the best gf he has got...please help.
You're going to have to relax a bit, or this will make you crazy.
Bottom Line:
Be the best person you can be. What will be will be. You can't control the future.
Dear Doc:
I AM A 76 YEAR OLD WIDOW. I DO NOT NOT WANT TO HAVE RELATIONS WITH ANOTHER MAN. IS IT WRONG FOR ME TO MASTERBATE?
It is not wrong. It is all good!
Bottom Line:
Just like it is natural to eat food or breathe air. It's part of how we're made, and part of what we need for good health.
Dear Doc:
What to do when your boyfriend has a drug habit and is hitting you up for money and feels you should not be mad?
How about...lose the boyfriend!!
Bottom Line:
There is no doubt that you can do better than this. Don't settle for crumbs.
Dear Doc:
hey, this is the 19 year old who talked abt the 1-2 week severe depression. thank you for your response. I'm just wondering if there are certain foods i should stay away from and what foods i should eat? everytime i go to a fast food resturaunt, whether it be Wendy's, Mc Donalds, places like that, I'll get veryyy tired and need a nap; afterwards i'll become anxious and a little paranoid. so i'm wondering if certain foods trigger it and what foods will help me?? thank you
Yes, foods can have a significant affect on your moods. Go online to study which foods affect which moods. There is a lot that is written about it nowadays. Also ask your Doctor for some reading materials.
Bottom Line:
It usually has to do with foods that are high in sugar, salt, and fat. More fruits and vegetables, as well as whole-grain breads will probably help.
Dear Doc:
my wife was diagnosed with biopolar. she has racing thoughts 24/7. she doesn't want to work any more, and is always attacking me verbally, and sometimes physically. i tried to help her but i can't seem to keep up with her antics. its bringing me and my kids down. i've spoken to her doctor about her ways,and all he does is prescribe more medication. she has a lot of anxiety. one anxiety is that she fears things are going to happen to me and our kids. she wont let them be by themselves or go to school on there own. my kids are 20 and 15 years of age. she tells me not to interfere with her way of thinking. it's driving us crazy. i told her doctor that she needs to be put away for treatment and evaluation, because she really needs it...thank you
Yours is one of the toughest rows to hoe. These people are usually better on their meds, but they often don't take them.
Bottom Line:
You may have to not live with her. Having her go in the hospital would help while she's gone, but odds are she would go off her meds when she gets out, which would just recreate the problem.
Dear Doc:
I'm 19, female. I have these intense 1-2 week periods of severe depression where I'm hopeless that I'm not good enough for myself or others and I just really hate myself and think some people are better than me. The strangest thing is sometimes I think I'm just as good as them. Combined with that, I experience, slight paranoia where I think people are laughing at me or trying to avoid me or are mad at me and I said something wrong and they don't like me anymore. Sometimes I even think people know what I'm thinking. During the depressive states I get in, I have extreme crying spells about anything, whether it be about something touching I see on tv, or just a sad thought and hoplessness and confusion I can't quite put together in my mind. I'll get irrational obsessive thoughts that scare me and I'm really close to my mom and I tell her everything so I have her reassure me in my wierd 2 week states I call it. I hate them. But the thing is they don't stay. It goes away for a while. Maybe every other month or so. And the weird thing is it's always around my menstural time. And I find the sunshine helps me feel better. I'm on a birth control that is suppossed to help with these ups and downs but i've only been on it for a week now. And when these 1-2 week episodes go away, I get happy again and I'm OK. I also have a bad memory problem. Is there something wrong with me?
It's most likely that there's nothing wrong with you that a hormonal adjustment won't fix. Many women take birth control pills to solve these problems. Your problem is probably more biological than psychological. The reason it happens every other month is that your ovaries alternate, and it's common that one of them causes more of these problems than the other.
Bottom Line:
You may need a specialist to give you the right hormones in the right amounts. If this first round of birth control doesn't help, seek out someone who specializes in this. Some talk therapy would probably be helpful also, to help you come to understand your situation, and how you can cope with the irrational moments.
Dear Doc:
I am trying to decide what type of Dr. I need to see. I have severe anxiety attacks, then can go into depression within an instance. Crying etc. From looking on the outside you may think that I have a great life, but there is something missing for me. I do not like myself at all, feel like I want to just stay in my home...no self esteem, mad at the world...I am taking care of my elderly mom, my oldest daughter and good friend has moved over 1500 miles away...I am 'pre' menopausal...gaining weight...no willpower when it comes to exercise or eating...work a full time job....Should i see my MD for depression meds, or a therapist? I just want my life back!
It is usually best to go to a therapist first, to try talk therapy. If that doesn't help, then and MD and medicine make sense.
Bottom Line:
However, your hormonal symptoms would suggest that there is a biological piece to your struggle, so going to both types of Doctors at the same time is reasonable. It's just that Pychiatrists usually aren't the easist folks to talk to, and regular MD's don't know enough about psychotropic medicines to necessarily give you the best advise. The good news is that there is help out there for you, and you CAN get your life back!
Dear Doc:
my sons wife left him, she has two daughters, one daughter is 12 and the other is 4. my son has been the 4 yrs father since birth. at first the mother would not let him see the 4 yr old, but since easter week-end he has been seeing her every other week-end and on wednesday evening. the mother now states that when the child comes home from visitation all she wants is to be with her daddy and live with him. the mother appears to be stopping the visitations, as my son was suppose to get her on friday 5/4/07 but has not happened as yet. please advise as course of action, i know the child is very attached to my son and he with her, he considers her as his very own. thank you.
He probably can't do much about it, if he has no legal rights to her.
Bottom Line:
All he can do is ask the mother to consider what is best for the child.
Dear Doc:
I've been dating my boyfreind for 5 months. He seems a lil too attached which i've gotten used to... the one thing i cannot seem to get used to is having to talk to him up to 3-5 times (about 1-2hr each) a day. When i tell him that maybe we should shorten our telephone times he gets upset and says that i'm just not that interested in him. That is not true; i love being around him. Is it normal for me not wanting to talk to him that much through the phone...i'm not sure why he gets upset..about it. Another problem is that he used to say "i love you" plenty...after i had told him that it loses meaning with it being sooo casual he got upset and brought it up again..that i'm not interested in him...anyway i was wondering if there is any way of explaining things to him without him getting too upset about them...or is it just me?
It's not just you. This guy is WAY to needy!
Bottom Line:
The relationship will never last if he doesn't learn to be more independent. He will drive you away if he doesn't change (and odds are he won't). Tell him now, so that he can either get his act together or you can move on to someone who isn't so clingy.
Dear Doc:
My boyfriend is overly jealous, and gets really annoyed if I stand too close to another man. We are supposed to be getting married in a couple of months and right now we are not speaking over one of his jealousy attacks. What should I do?
Don't get married right now!
Bottom Line:
Jealousy can be a cancer, and usually is a red flag for insecurity. Go get some serious couples therapy, if you want a chance at a good marriage down the road.
Dear Doc:
last time child saw father she was 8 months old. he abandoned her. now in may she'll be 4 yrs old. the father was given visitation every sat and overnight every other sat. she does not know him and i fear him because of his violant behavior. i'm currently fighting the visitation he was given. I was not there to present my case. in your opinion would this traumatize her?
It could be most difficult for her, depending on how you present it to her.
Bottom Line:
Unfortunately, she will probably be the loser in this situation, regardless whether your case is heard or not.
Dear Doc:
To add something else to my story which i posted yesterday about my wife of twenty two years is that this girl has done this before. Our friend who we lost contact with explained this to me. This is where my wife met her because we lost contact with our friend. I have found entries in a diary saying she was meeting this girl over twelve month ago outside a bar. I went abroad to help my brother in law with my wife volunteering me to help him with some building work. I rang home to see if everthing was ok. my son answered the phone. i asked to speak to his mum. he said she had gone out at 1:30pm walking the dog. the time i rang was 7:30pm. another baffling thing is she say's she can't afford to divorce me or people separate and get back together in a few years. Since the separation i have helped her to buy a new car, fit a new washing machine even though i am disable through arthritis, sorting out a bank loan with her because she had more going out than coming in. My son walked out with me. he say's that i am the better parent. my daughter is just down right nasty with me saying her mum doesn't want anything to do with me or swearing down the phone at me then hanging up. i have asked my wife to have a word with her. all she say's is that she is entitled to her own opinion. This weekend just gone she slept out for 2 night's leaving my daughter at home with this girl's mum who i don't know. she could of invited anybody in where my daughter was. Another strange thing that has happened is she has put the family home up for sale. Don't think i am being paranoid, but i asked my brother who is gay to see if i could make sense of the changes in my wife. his boyfriend said it sounds like she is being manipulated in a certain way which did make sense after he explained it because it had happened to him. if this is true i need some serious help because my wife will lose everything because of this girl. thanks.
Don't let your wife off the hook so easily. She is still responsible for her own actions.
Bottom Line:
She is taking you to the cleaners. You'd better get an attorney asap to protect you from total financial and family ruin.
Dear Doc:
I have been with my wife for twenty two years. Just over a year ago i found out she was writing e-mails to a gay female and text messages on her phone. She started to go out with this girl and was coming in at ludicrous times of the morning ranging from 4.30 to 6.30 in a morning. I was finished from work due to ill health and was asked to become a house husband with which i duelly obliged whilst she went to work. I made sure the house was clean, the children were picked up from school, then had their tea. i did everthing a house husband should do. She said that her and this girl were friends nothing else. Please don't judge me on what i am about to write. When i found the text messages on her phone i just went mad after being out for a drink and physically abused her. I have been to counselling to try and understand why i did this. My wife is still seeing this girl 10 months after separating from me, staying out all night and leaving my daughter with complete strangers who i don't know. I have never been physically abusive to my wife before in all the time we have been together. She seems now to have just dumped me like a boyfriend and will not talk to me when i contact her. There is more to this story, but i don't want to sound like a bleeding heart. Thanks.
|